Translate this page into:
A novel flexible exponential-G family: Properties, estimation, and applications in environmental and engineering sciences
*Corresponding author E-mail address: ahmed.afify@fcom.bu.edu.eg (A. Z. Afify)
-
Received: ,
Accepted: ,
Abstract
In this paper, we propose a new family of continuous probability distributions, referred to as the flexible exponential-G (FEx-G) family, which generalizes and extends several well-known distributions. This family is highly flexible and possesses desirable properties. We introduce a variety of new distributions as special cases within the FEx-G family, including the well-known flexible-Weibull distribution. A key special case, the flexible exponential-inverse Lomax-Lomax (FExILL) distribution, is studied in detail. We present characterizations of the FExILL distribution based on its hazard function, and derive the probability density function for the order statistics of this distribution. Additionally, we discuss seven methods for estimating the parameters of the FExILL distribution. To evaluate the performance of these estimation methods, we conduct a simulation study. Finally, we demonstrate the practical application and flexibility of the FExILL distribution by modeling three real-world datasets from applied fields such as environmental, mechanical engineering, and reliability engineering. The results show that the FExILL distribution outperforms other competing distributions, making it a robust choice for modeling real-world data.
Keywords
Failure time data
Inverse lomax
maximum likelihood
Order statistics
Quantile function
1. Introduction
In applied science, selecting the appropriate probability distribution for modeling and analyzing data is essential for more precise conclusions. Real-life datasets, particularly in reliability and failure times fields, often exhibit unimodal, modified unimodal, or bathtub-shaped (U-shaped) FRF patterns. Employing traditional distributions to accommodate these data sets could lead to inaccurate results. Thus, numerous probability distributions have been suggested to suit various types of real-life data. Moreover, enhancing the flexibility of the conventional distributions is an important requirement. The literature on probability distribution techniques contains a range of expansions and enhancements of continuous, discrete, symmetric, and asymmetric distributions. One of the most important of these techniques is to build a new family to generate many flexible probability distributions.
Recently, several methods and approaches have been introduced to construct new statistical distributions, reflecting their importance in modeling real data across diverse fields such as biology, reliability engineering, economics, and environmental sciences. Among the most notable families are Azzalini’s skewed family (Azzalini, 1985), Marshall-Olkin family (Marshall and Olkin, 1997), exponentiated family (Gupta et al., 1998), beta-generated family (Eugene et al., 2002), Kumaraswamy-G (Cordeiro and De Castro, 2011), McDonald-G (Alexander et al., 2012), exponentiated transformed transformer (Alzaghal et al., 2013), exponentiated generalized (Cordeiro et al., 2013), Weibull-G (Bourguignon et al., 2014), new power Topp-Leone family (Bantan et al., (2019), generalized exponential-G (Tahir, et al., 2016), alpha power transformation (Mahdavi and Kundu, 2017), Marshall-Olkin-Weibull-H (Afify et al., 2022), weighted Lindley-G (Alnssyan et al., 2023), sine generalized family (Oramulu et al., 2024), generalized Kavya-Manoharan-G (Mahran et al., 2024), modified Kies flexible generalized family (Ferreira and Cordeiro, 2024), Pi-power logistic-G (Sapkota et al., 2025), shifted Lomax-X (Atchadé et al., 2025), sine modified-Kies generalized family (Mulagala and Nagarjuna, 2025), modified Kies Kavya-Manoharan-G (Hamdi et al., 2025), and Marshall-Olkin alpha log-power transformed-G (Musekwa and Makubate, 2025).
While these families provide valuable extensions, classical distributions still face limitations in capturing diverse hazard rate (HR) shapes and tail behaviors. In particular, many generalized models achieve flexibility only by introducing additional parameters, which often increases complexity and complicates estimation. This limitation motivates the development of new frameworks that achieve both parsimony and adaptability, a gap that the proposed flexible exponential-G (FEx-G) family seeks to address.
Motivated by these challenges, we introduce the FEx-G family, we propose the FEx-G family. This family not only generalizes and extends several well-known distributions but also offers high flexibility in modeling diverse data behaviors. A particularly interesting feature is the presence of a special subfamily capable of combining two different baseline distributions without introducing any additional parameters, thereby achieving a unique balance between simplicity and adaptability. Furthermore, the FEx-G family can accommodate a wide spectrum of HR behaviors, including modified bathtub, decreasing, bathtub, increasing, J-shape, reversed J-shape, and unimodal shapes. These properties, illustrated through specific submodels and graphical analyses in later sections, demonstrate the strong potential of the FEx-G family for both theoretical research and practical applications, particularly in survival analysis and reliability studies.
To strengthen practical applicability, we investigate seven parameter estimation techniques for a notable special case of the proposed FEx-G family, namely the FExILL model. Using extensive simulation studies under various parameter settings and for both small and large sample sizes, we assess and compare the performance of these methods. The findings provide deeper insights into the properties of the FEx-G family while offering applied researchers, engineers, and statisticians clear guidance on selecting effective estimation strategies for real-world applications.
The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 defines the FEx-G family. Section 3 discusses four special sub-models of the FEx-G family. Section 4 provides some mathematical properties of the FExILL model. Section 5 discusses parameter estimation of the FExILL model. Section 6 presents simulation results to examine the behavior of different estimators. Section 7 investigates practical applications using real-world data. Finally, Section 8 concludes the paper with a summary of the main findings and remarks.
2. The New Family
In this section, we develop a new family of distributions called the FEx-G class and derive some of its properties. The cumulative distribution function (CDF) of the FEx-G family is defined by
where and are two baseline CDFs with vectors of unknown parameters and respectively, 0 and are two extra shape parameters.
The probability density function (PDF) corresponding to Equation (2.1) is given by
where is the PDF of the first baseline distribution with parameter vector and is the HR function (HRF) corresponding to the second baseline distribution with parameter vector .
From Equations (2.1) and (2.2), the HRF of the FEx-G family reduces to
Equation (2.3) shows that the HRF depends on the values of the parameters and w.
Furthermore, the FEx-G family has two important special cases as follows. Two baseline distributions are identical with the same parameter vector
The PDF and FRF corresponding to Equation (2.4) are given by
and
An important special case of the FEx-G family arises when . The reduced family is capable of generating new flexible distributions without introducing any additional parameters to the baseline distributions.
The CDF, PDF, and HRF of the reduced family are defined as follows
and
3. Special Sub-Models
This section presents several special sub-models of the FEx-G family by employing different baseline distributions, namely the uniform (U), inverse exponential (IEx), exponential (Ex), Fréchet (F), Weibull (W), inverse Lomax (IL), and Lomax (L). The resulting sub-models include the FEx-uniform uniform (FExUU), FEx-inverse exponential exponential (FExIExEx), FEx-Fréchet Weibull (FExFW), and FEx-inverse Lomax Lomax (FExILL) distributions.
3.1 The FExUU distribution
Let for be a common baseline U distribution with a scale parameter . Then, from Equation (2.4), the CDF of the FExUU distribution reduces to
The PDF and HRF of the FExUU distribution are given by
and
This distribution is commonly referred to in the literature as the Kies distribution (Kies, 1958). Illustrative shapes of the PDF and HRF of the FExUU distribution have been presented in Fig. 1
PDF and HRF Plots of the FExUU density for different parametric values.
3.2 The FExIExEx distribution
We define the FExIExEx distribution by taking the IEx and Ex distributions as baseline distributions in the FEx-G family. Consider the CDF of the IEx distribution with parameter , for , and the CDF of the Ex distribution with parameters , for . Then, the CDF of the FExIExEx distribution can be derived from Equation (2.7) as
The PDF and HRF of the FExIExEx distribution are defined by
and
This distribution is referred to in the literature as the flexible Weibull distribution (Bebbington et al, 2007). Representative shapes of its density and HR functions have been illustrated in Fig. 2
PDF and HRF plots of the FExIExEx density for different parametric values.
3.3 The FExFW distribution
The CDFs of the F and W distributions are, respectively, and JKSUS820_039 - Copy.eps]. The CDF of the FExFW distribution can then be derived from Equation (2.7) as follows:
The PDF and HRF of the FExFW distribution are derived as
and
This distribution is known in the literature as the new flexible extended Weibull distribution, and it is introduced by Qinghu Liao et. al. (2020). Some shapes of the density and failure rate functions of the FExIExEx distribution have been displayed in Fig. 3.

- PDF and HRF Plots of the FExFW density for different parametric values.
This distribution is known in the literature as the new flexible extended Weibull distribution (Liao et al., 2020). Some possible shapes of its PDF and HRF have been displayed in Fig. 3.
3.4 The FExILL distribution
In this section, we introduce the FExILL distribution as a special case of the FEx-G family, with support [0, ), and derive some of its properties. The CDF of the FExILL distribution is obtained by substituting the CDFs of the IL and L baseline distributions into the general CDF form of the FEx-G family.
The CDFs of the IL and L distributions are given by
Then, the CDF of the FExILL distribution follows from Equation (2.7) as
The cumulative HRF, HRF and PDF of the FExILL distribution are expressed as follows
and
Let us consider the special case where the IL and L distributions share a common scale parameter, i.e., . Then:
and
The HRF of the FExILL distribution has the form
Representative shapes of the PDF and HRF of the FExILL distribution have been displayed in Fig. 4.

- PDF and HRF Plots of the FExILL density for different parametric values.
4. Properties of the FExILL Model
The shape of the HRF of the FExILL model can be described analytically.
The critical points of the FRF are the solutions of the equation:
The two change points , the turning points of the HRF, are
Clearly, the shape of the HRF of the FExILL model, denoted by, , is influenced by the parameters and through the terms and
Case (i): and :
as and as .
is decreasing in , implying it has a decreasing shape.
Case (ii): and :
as , and as .
initially decreases and then increases, implying it has a bathtub shape.
Case (iii): and :
as , and as .
initially increases and then decreases, implying it has a unimodal shape.
Case (iv): and :
as and as .
is increasing in , implying it has an increasing shape.
Thus, the FExILL distribution can accommodate various HR shapes, including increasing, decreasing, bathtub, and unimodal, demonstrating its flexibility for modeling survival and reliability data.
4.1 Mixture representation
This section provides a useful mixture representation of the CDF and the PDF of the FExILL distribution.
Consider the exponential series, which is given by
Applying (4.1) to Equation (3.1), we obtain
Consider the binomial series, which is given by
So that, the following terms can be expressed as:
and
Hence, the CDF of the FExILL model reduces to
IT also can be rewritten as
where .
Differentiating the last equation, the PDF of the FExILL distribution can be expressed as
where .
4.2 Moments
The raw moments of the FExILL distribution can be obtained as follows
Rewrite and simplify the integrand, let us denote:
Then, the integrand becomes:
We expand the exponential using the power series. It follows that:
Substituting this into the integral:
Combining terms:
Using
So, we can write
Substituting back
Split into two terms
where
and
Change of variables
Let then
and
Substituting into the original expression:
We recognize the integrals as a standard form of the beta function
This identity holds for , . Applying this
So, the raw moments exists when only
Table 1 presents the first four non-central moments of the FExILL distribution for various values of and with . It is observed that as and increase, the moments generally decrease, reflecting the impact of these shape parameters on the distribution’s central tendency and variability. This illustrates the flexibility of the FExILL distribution in modeling different data behaviors.
| Parameters values | Non central moments | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.2 | * | * | * | * | |
| 0.5 | 1.289 | 1.143 | 1.059 | 1.000 | |
| 1.0 | 0.2 | 0.639 | 0.474 | 0.386 | 0.330 |
| 2.0 | 0.339 | 0.189 | 0.123 | 0.087 | |
| 5.0 | 0.137 | 0.043 | 0.018 | 0.008 | |
| 0.8 | 2.381 | 2.117 | 1.962 | 1.853 | |
| 1.0 | 1.477 | 1.219 | 1.072 | 0.973 | |
| 1.5 | 0.5 | 0752 | 0526 | 0.409 | 0.336 |
| 2.0 | 0.493 | 0.298 | 0.208 | 0.156 | |
| 5.0 | 0.136 | 0.046 | 0.020 | 0.010 | |
| 1.6 | 1.879 | 1.537 | 1.333 | 1.192 | |
| 2.0 | 1.000 | 0.727 | 0.576 | 0.478 | |
| 3.0 | 1.0 | 0.381 | 0.216 | 0.141 | 0.099 |
| 5.0 | 0.127 | 0.050 | 0.024 | 0.013 | |
| 7.0 | 0.063 | 0.019 | 0.007 | 0.003 | |
| 2.5 | 3.688 | 3.241 | 2.935 | 2.707 | |
| 3.0 | 1.286 | 1.004 | 0.827 | 0.704 | |
| 5.0 | 2.0 | 0.147 | 0.079 | 0.048 | 0.031 |
| 6.5 | 0.057 | 0.025 | 0.013 | 0.007 | |
| 8.0 | 0.028 | 0.010 | 0.004 | 0.002 | |
| 5.5 | 6.597 | 6.130 | 5.754 | 5.443 | |
| 6.0 | 1.616 | 1.401 | 1.237 | 1.108 | |
| 7.5 | 5.0 | 0.116 | 0.084 | 0.063 | 0.049 |
| 9.0 | 0.021 | 0.013 | 0.008 | 0.006 | |
| 10.0 | 0.008 | 0.005 | 0.003 | 0.002 | |
4.3 Skewness and kurtosis
In this section, we derive the skewness ( ) and kurtosis ( ) of the FExILL distribution. Khan et al. (2021) proposed a measure for the skewness based on the CDF. This measure uses the CDF evaluated at the mean as a key component of the skewness measure aligns naturally with the tendency of the mean to shift in the direction of skewness. According to Khan et al. (2021), the skewness measure is defined as:
where is the value of the CDF at the mean . Using the CDF (3.1) and the mean of the FExILL distribution, we can write
where is the mean of the FExILL distribution, which can be obtained from the first non-central moment ( ) as follows (for ):
For the kurtosis measure, we adopt the following definition:
Fig. 5 illustrates the behavior of skewness ( ) and kurtosis ( ) for the FExILL distribution across different values of and with fixed at . Both measures and increase as the parameters increase. The skewness values remain within the range of to as expected (see Khan et al., 2021), indicating moderate asymmetry in the distribution.

- Plots of the skewness and kurtosis of the FExILL distribution.
4.4 Quantile function
The quantile function (QF) of the FExILL distribution is obtained by inverting (3.1) as:
4.5 Order statistics
The order statistics for the FExILL distribution are discussed in this section.
It is useful to derive the PDF of the order statistic of a random sample drawn from the FExILL with parameters and .
The PDF of the order statistic is given by
Using the CDF (3.1) of the FExILL distribution, we obtain
and
Substituting the last two equations in the first equation, we get (for, )
Therefore, the PDF of the largest order statistic is given by
The PDF of the smallest order statistic is given by
5. Estimation methods
In this section, we present seven methods for estimating the parameters of the FExILL distribution. These methods include maximum likelihood (ML), least squares (LS), weighted least squares (WLS), Cramér-von Mises (CVM), maximum product of spacings (MPS), Anderson-Darling (AD), and right-tail Anderson-Darling (RTAD) estimators.
Let be a random sample from the FExILL distribution with parameters and . Denote the ordered statistics as .
The log-likelihood function of the FExILL model can be expressed as follows
where and .
The MLEs for and can be obtained by maximizing the previous equation with respect to these parameters or by solving the provided nonlinear equations:
and
The LS and WLS methods are employed to estimate the parameters of the beta distribution (Swain et al., 1988). The LS estimators (LSEs) and WLS estimators (WLSEs) for the FExILL parameters can be obtained by minimizing the following:
where for the LS method, for the WLS approach, and and .
Additionally, the LSEs and WLSEs can be derived by solving the nonlinear equations (for ):
where
and
The CVM estimators (CVMEs) (Cramér, 1928 and Von Mises, 1928) can be derived from the difference between the estimated CDF and the empirical CDF. The CVMEs for the FExILL parameters are found by minimizing the following function:
Further, the CVMEs follow by solving the nonlinear equations,
where are defined in (1)-(3) for .
The MPS method is used for parameter estimation in continuous univariate models as an alternative to the ML method (Cheng and Amin, 1979, 1983). The niform spacings of a random sample of size from the FExILL distribution can be characterized by:
where denotes the uniform spacings, where and . The MPS estimators (MPSEs) of the FExILL parameters can be obtained by maximizing
Additionally, the MPSEs of the FExILL parameters can also be obtained by solving:
The AD estimators (ADEs) are another form of minimum distance estimator. The ADEs for the FExILL parameters are obtained by minimizing:
The ADEs can also be determined by solving the corresponding nonlinear equations:
The RTAD estimators (RTADEs) for the FExILL parameters and are obtained by minimizing the following function with respect to these parameters:
6. Simulation Analysis
This section examines the efficacy of seven estimation methods for the FExILL parameters through a simulation study. We generate 5000 samples from the FExILL distribution across several sample sizes, specifically , and for a range of parametric values, including , and . To assess the performance of the estimators under investigation, we compute the average biases (BIAS), mean square errors (MSE), and mean relative errors (MRE) for each estimate.
Tables 2-9 present the BIAS, MSE, and MRE for the MLEs, LSEs, WLSEs, MPSEs, PCEs, CVMEs, ADEs, and RTADEs. Additionally, Table 10 provides the partial and overall ranks of the mentioned estimators. It is important to note that the MSE, BIAS, and MRE tend to approach zero with an increased sample size. Moreover, the MSE values converge to zero, indicating that all estimators are asymptotically unbiased. Based on the data presented in Tables 2-9, it can be concluded that all seven estimation methods exhibit better performance. Table 10 demonstrates that the MLEs surpass all other estimators, achieving an overall score of 64.5 Therefore, our study confirms the superior performance of the MPSEs in estimating the FExILL parameters.
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.35730{4} | 0.38227{7} | 0.35045{3} | 0.37981{6} | 0.32625{1} | 0.33992{2} | 0.36426{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.09607{3} | 0.10827{5} | 0.10076{4} | 0.11181{6} | 0.09517{2} | 0.09353{1} | 0.12105{7} | ||
| 0.11937{2} | 0.15087{6} | 0.12887{5} | 0.15448{7} | 0.11551{1} | 0.12070{3} | 0.12191{4} | |||
| 0.12766{4} | 0.14613{7} | 0.12281{3} | 0.14425{6} | 0.10644{1} | 0.11555{2} | 0.13268{5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.00923{3} | 0.01172{5} | 0.01015{4} | 0.01250{6} | 0.00906{2} | 0.00875{1} | 0.01465{7} | |
| 0.01425{2} | 0.02276{6} | 0.01661{5} | 0.02386{7} | 0.01334{1} | 0.01457{3} | 0.01486{4} | |||
| 0.47640{4} | 0.50970{7} | 0.46726{3} | 0.50641{6} | 0.43500{1} | 0.45323{2} | 0.48568{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.19214{3} | 0.21654{5} | 0.20151{4} | 0.22361{6} | 0.19034{2} | 0.18706{1} | 0.24209{7} | ||
| 0.23874{2} | 0.30174{6} | 0.25775{5} | 0.30895{7} | 0.23103{1} | 0.24139{3} | 0.24383{4} | |||
| 27.0{3} | 54.0{6} | 36.0{4} | 57.0{7} | 12.0{1} | 18.0{2} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.20384{2} | 0.23289{6} | 0.21812{4} | 0.23364{7} | 0.19297{1} | 0.21168{3} | 0.22571{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.05529{1} | 0.06497{5} | 0.05924{4} | 0.06619{6} | 0.05712{2} | 0.05814{3} | 0.07158{7} | ||
| 0.06836{2} | 0.09193{7} | 0.07534{5} | 0.09127{6} | 0.06772{1} | 0.07311{3} | 0.07313{4} | |||
| 0.04155{2} | 0.05424{6} | 0.04757{4} | 0.05459{7} | 0.03724{1} | 0.04481{3} | 0.05095{5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.00306{1} | 0.00422{5} | 0.00351{4} | 0.00438{6} | 0.00326{2} | 0.00338{3} | 0.00512{7} | |
| 0.00467{2} | 0.00845{7} | 0.00568{5} | 0.00833{6} | 0.00459{1} | 0.00535{3.5} | 0.00535{3.5} | |||
| 0.27178{2} | 0.31052{6} | 0.29082{4} | 0.31152{7} | 0.25729{1} | 0.28225{3} | 0.30095{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.11058{1} | 0.12994{5} | 0.11847{4} | 0.13237{6} | 0.11424{2} | 0.11629{3} | 0.14317{7} | ||
| 0.13671{2} | 0.18387{7} | 0.15069{5} | 0.18254{6} | 0.13543{1} | 0.14622{3} | 0.14626{4} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 54.0{6} | 39.0{4} | 57.0{7} | 12.0{1} | 27.5{3} | 47.5{5} | |||
| 0.18121{2} | 0.21419{7} | 0.19091{4} | 0.20400{6} | 0.17633{1} | 0.18599{3} | 0.19800{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.04824{1} | 0.05737{5} | 0.05269{4} | 0.05820{6} | 0.04943{2} | 0.05155{3} | 0.06203{7} | ||
| 0.05861{2} | 0.08642{7} | 0.06730{5} | 0.07862{6} | 0.0583{01} | 0.06422{3} | 0.06515{4} | |||
| 0.03284{2} | 0.04588{7} | 0.03645{4} | 0.04161{6} | 0.03109{1} | 0.03459{3} | 0.03920{5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.00233{1} | 0.00329{5} | 0.00278{4} | 0.00339{6} | 0.00244{2} | 0.00266{3} | 0.00385{7} | |
| 0.00344{2} | 0.00747{7} | 0.00453{5} | 0.00618{6} | 0.00340{1} | 0.00412{3} | 0.00424{4} | |||
| 0.24161{2} | 0.28559{7} | 0.25455{4} | 0.27200{6} | 0.23510{1} | 0.24799{3} | 0.26400{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.09648{1} | 0.11475{5} | 0.10537{4} | 0.11641{6} | 0.09886{2} | 0.10311{3} | 0.12405{7} | ||
| 0.11722{2} | 0.17285{7} | 0.13460{5} | 0.15725{6} | 0.11661{1} | 0.12844{3} | 0.13030{4} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 57.0{7} | 39.0{4} | 54.0{6} | 12.0{1} | 27.0{3} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.10571{2} | 0.12274{6} | 0.11198{4} | 0.12463{7} | 0.10304{1} | 0.10879{3} | 0.11638{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.02806{1} | 0.03294{5} | 0.02947{2} | 0.03461{6} | 0.02957{3} | 0.02994{4} | 0.03572{7} | ||
| 0.03301{1} | 0.04596{6} | 0.03703{4} | 0.04742{7} | 0.03399{2} | 0.03657{3} | 0.03744{5} | |||
| 0.01118{2} | 0.01507{6} | 0.01254{4} | 0.01553{7} | 0.01062{1} | 0.01184{3} | 0.01354{5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.00079{1} | 0.00109{5} | 0.00087{2.5} | 0.00120{6} | 0.00087{2.5} | 0.00090{4} | 0.00128{7} | |
| 0.00109{1} | 0.00211{6} | 0.00137{4} | 0.00225{7} | 0.00116{2} | 0.00134{3} | 0.0014{05} | |||
| 0.14095{2} | 0.16366{6} | 0.14930{4} | 0.16617{7} | 0.13739{1} | 0.14506{3} | 0.15518{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.05612{1} | 0.06589{5} | 0.05894{2} | 0.06921{6} | 0.05914{3} | 0.05987{4} | 0.07143{7} | ||
| 0.06602{1} | 0.09192{6} | 0.07406{4} | 0.09484{7} | 0.06797{2} | 0.07314{3} | 0.07487{5} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 51.0{5.5} | 30.5{4} | 60.0{7} | 17.5{2} | 30.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.07895{1} | 0.09474{6} | 0.08606{4} | 0.09555{7} | 0.08001{2} | 0.08585{3} | 0.09026{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.02246{2} | 0.02629{6} | 0.02269{4} | 0.02597{5} | 0.02162{1} | 0.02261{3} | 0.02807{7} | ||
| 0.02625{2} | 0.03639{7} | 0.02901{5} | 0.03583{6} | 0.02600{1} | 0.02824{3} | 0.02865{4} | |||
| 0.00623{1} | 0.00898{6} | 0.00741{4} | 0.00913{7} | 0.00640{2} | 0.00737{3} | 0.00815{5} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.00050{2} | 0.00069{6} | 0.00051{3.5} | 0.00067{5} | 0.00047{1} | 0.00051{3.5} | 0.00079{7} | |
| 0.00069{2} | 0.00132{7} | 0.00084{5} | 0.00128{6} | 0.00068{1} | 0.00080{3} | 0.00082{4} | |||
| 0.10526{1} | 0.12632{6} | 0.11475{4} | 0.12741{7} | 0.10668{2} | 0.11447{3} | 0.12035{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.04493{2} | 0.05258{6} | 0.04538{4} | 0.05195{5} | 0.04324{1} | 0.04521{3} | 0.05613{7} | ||
| 0.05249{2} | 0.07279{7} | 0.05801{5} | 0.07166{6} | 0.05199{1} | 0.05647{3} | 0.05730{4} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 57.0{7} | 38.5{4} | 54.0{6} | 12.0{1} | 27.5{3} | 48.0{5} |
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.35567{2} | 0.43323{7} | 0.38543{4} | 0.42565{6} | 0.34752{1} | 0.36153{3} | 0.40281{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.09951{1} | 0.12626{6} | 0.11256{4} | 0.12442{5} | 0.10662{3} | 0.10320{2} | 0.13436{7} | ||
| 0.56424{1} | 0.72594{7} | 0.63502{5} | 0.72209{6} | 0.56929{2} | 0.58500{3} | 0.62120{4} | |||
| 0.12650{2} | 0.18769{7} | 0.14855{4} | 0.18117{6} | 0.12077{1} | 0.13070{3} | 0.16225{5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.00990{1} | 0.01594{6} | 0.01267{4} | 0.01548{5} | 0.01137{3} | 0.01065{2} | 0.01805{7} | |
| 0.31837{1} | 0.52699{7} | 0.40325{5} | 0.52141{6} | 0.32409{2} | 0.34223{3} | 0.38589{4} | |||
| 0.47423{2} | 0.57764{7} | 0.51390{4} | 0.56753{6} | 0.46336{1} | 0.48204{3} | 0.53708{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.19902{1} | 0.25253{6} | 0.22513{4} | 0.24883{5} | 0.21324{3} | 0.20641{2} | 0.26873{7} | ||
| 0.37616{1} | 0.48396{7} | 0.42335{5} | 0.48139{6} | 0.37953{2} | 0.39{3} | 0.41413{4} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 60.0{7} | 39.0{4} | 51.0{6} | 18.0{2} | 24.0{3} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.22041{2} | 0.27207{6} | 0.24132{4} | 0.27389{7} | 0.20643{1} | 0.23301{3} | 0.24301{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.06017{2} | 0.07636{6} | 0.06603{4} | 0.07510{5} | 0.05891{1} | 0.06446{3} | 0.07903{7} | ||
| 0.34373{2} | 0.46456{7} | 0.39674{5} | 0.46455{6} | 0.33745{1} | 0.37123{3} | 0.37387{4} | |||
| 0.04858{2} | 0.07402{6} | 0.05823{4} | 0.07502{7} | 0.04261{1} | 0.05429{3} | 0.05905{5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.00362{2} | 0.00583{6} | 0.00436{4} | 0.00564{5} | 0.00347{1} | 0.00416{3} | 0.00625{7} | |
| 0.11815{2} | 0.21582{7} | 0.15740{5} | 0.21581{6} | 0.11387{1} | 0.13781{3} | 0.13978{4} | |||
| 0.29388{2} | 0.36275{6} | 0.32176{4} | 0.36519{7} | 0.27524{1} | 0.31068{3} | 0.32401{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.12033{2} | 0.15272{6} | 0.13206{4} | 0.15019{5} | 0.11781{1} | 0.12892{3} | 0.15806{7} | ||
| 0.22915{2} | 0.30971{7} | 0.26449{5} | 0.30970{6} | 0.22496{1} | 0.24749{3} | 0.24925{4} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 57.0{7} | 39.0{4} | 54.0{6} | 9.0{1} | 27.0{3} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.19411{2} | 0.24405{6} | 0.21716{4} | 0.24574{7} | 0.18812{1} | 0.21039{3} | 0.22339{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.05365{1} | 0.06840{6} | 0.05925{4} | 0.06756{5} | 0.05512{2} | 0.05719{3} | 0.06952{7} | ||
| 0.30377{2} | 0.41230{6} | 0.35655{5} | 0.41871{7} | 0.29968{1} | 0.34342{4} | 0.34212{3} | |||
| 0.03768{2} | 0.05956{6} | 0.04716{4} | 0.06039{7} | 0.03539{1} | 0.04426{3} | 0.04990{5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.00288{1} | 0.00468{6} | 0.00351{4} | 0.00456{5} | 0.00304{2} | 0.00327{3} | 0.00483{7} | |
| 0.09228{2} | 0.16999{6} | 0.12713{5} | 0.17532{7} | 0.08981{1} | 0.11794{4} | 0.11705{3} | |||
| 0.25882{2} | 0.32540{6} | 0.28954{4} | 0.32766{7} | 0.25083{1} | 0.28052{3} | 0.29785{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.10730{1} | 0.13680{6} | 0.11850{4} | 0.13513{5} | 0.11023{2} | 0.11437{3} | 0.13904{7} | ||
| 0.20251{2} | 0.27487{6} | 0.23770{5} | 0.27914{7} | 0.19979{1} | 0.22895{4} | 0.22808{3} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 54.0{6} | 39.0{4} | 57.0{7} | 12.0{1} | 30.0{3} | 45.0{5} | |||
| 0.10988{1} | 0.14289{7} | 0.11983{4} | 0.14121{6} | 0.11080{2} | 0.11944{3} | 0.13391{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.03091{2} | 0.03821{5} | 0.03164{3} | 0.03906{6} | 0.03080{1} | 0.03261{4} | 0.04140{7} | ||
| 0.17594{1} | 0.24237{7} | 0.19786{4} | 0.23915{6} | 0.17611{2} | 0.19354{3} | 0.20571{5} | |||
| 0.01207{1} | 0.02042{7} | 0.01436{4} | 0.01994{6} | 0.01228{2} | 0.01427{3} | 0.01793{5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.00096{2} | 0.00146{5} | 0.00100{3} | 0.00153{6} | 0.00095{1} | 0.00106{4} | 0.00171{7} | |
| 0.03096{1} | 0.05874{7} | 0.03915{4} | 0.05720{6} | 0.03102{2} | 0.03746{3} | 0.04232{5} | |||
| 0.14651{1} | 0.19051{7} | 0.15977{4} | 0.18828{6} | 0.14773{2} | 0.15925{3} | 0.17855{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.06182{2} | 0.07642{5} | 0.06327{3} | 0.07812{6} | 0.06159{1} | 0.06521{4} | 0.08279{7} | ||
| 0.11729{1} | 0.16158{7} | 0.13191{4} | 0.15944{6} | 0.11741{2} | 0.12903{3} | 0.13714{5} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 57.0{7} | 33.0{4} | 54.0{6} | 15.0{2} | 30.0{3} | 51.0{5} | |||
| 0.08282{1} | 0.10861{6} | 0.08757{3} | 0.10994{7} | 0.08458{2} | 0.09370{4} | 0.10160{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.02360{2} | 0.02938{5} | 0.02501{3} | 0.02968{6} | 0.02336{1} | 0.02577{4} | 0.03180{7} | ||
| 0.12979{1} | 0.18373{6} | 0.14437{3} | 0.19012{7} | 0.13684{2} | 0.15361{4} | 0.15652{5} | |||
| 0.00686{1} | 0.01180{6} | 0.00767{3} | 0.01209{7} | 0.00715{2} | 0.00878{4} | 0.01032{5} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.00056{2} | 0.00086{5} | 0.00063{3} | 0.00088{6} | 0.00055{1} | 0.00066{4} | 0.00101{7} | |
| 0.01685{1} | 0.03376{6} | 0.02084{3} | 0.03615{7} | 0.01872{2} | 0.02360{4} | 0.02450{5} | |||
| 0.11043{1} | 0.14481{6} | 0.11676{3} | 0.14659{7} | 0.11277{2} | 0.12493{4} | 0.13546{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.04720{2} | 0.05876{5} | 0.05002{3} | 0.05937{6} | 0.04673{1} | 0.05154{4} | 0.06359{7} | ||
| 0.08653{1} | 0.12249{6} | 0.09624{3} | 0.12675{7} | 0.09122{2} | 0.10240{4} | 0.10435{5} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 51.0{5.5} | 27.0{3} | 60.0{7} | 15.0{2} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} |
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.47103{3} | 1.84917{6} | 1.62531{4} | 1.90669{7} | 1.41815{2} | 1.41210{1} | 1.79709{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.67817{3} | 0.84393{5} | 0.74531{4} | 0.85578{6} | 0.66714{1} | 0.67403{2} | 0.89420{7} | ||
| 0.12044{3} | 0.17220{6} | 0.14064{4} | 0.17665{7} | 0.11624{1} | 0.11988{2} | 0.14539{5} | |||
| 2.16393{3} | 3.41941{6} | 2.64162{4} | 3.63545{7} | 2.01116{2} | 1.99402{1} | 3.22952{5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.45991{3} | 0.71222{5} | 0.55548{4} | 0.73235{6} | 0.44507{1} | 0.45431{2} | 0.79960{7} | |
| 0.01450{3} | 0.02965{6} | 0.01978{4} | 0.03120{7} | 0.01351{1} | 0.01437{2} | 0.02114{5} | |||
| 0.49034{3} | 0.61639{6} | 0.54177{4} | 0.63556{7} | 0.47272{2} | 0.47070{1} | 0.59903{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.33908{3} | 0.42196{5} | 0.37265{4} | 0.42789{6} | 0.33357{1} | 0.33701{2} | 0.44710{7} | ||
| 0.24087{3} | 0.34440{6} | 0.28128{4} | 0.35330{7} | 0.23248{1} | 0.23976{2} | 0.29079{5} | |||
| 27.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | 36.0{4} | 60.0{7} | 12.0{1} | 15.0{2} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.80601{1} | 1.12175{6} | 0.89613{4} | 1.12198{7} | 0.81719{2} | 0.87562{3} | 1.10242{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.38425{1} | 0.54017{5} | 0.43885{4} | 0.54648{6} | 0.39245{2} | 0.41766{3} | 0.57279{7} | ||
| 0.06773{1} | 0.10283{7} | 0.07941{4} | 0.10184{6} | 0.07039{2} | 0.07659{3} | 0.08591{5} | |||
| 0.64966{1} | 1.25832{6} | 0.80306{4} | 1.25885{7} | 0.66780{2} | 0.76671{3} | 1.21534{5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.14765{1} | 0.29179{5} | 0.19259{4} | 0.29865{6} | 0.15401{2} | 0.17444{3} | 0.32809{7} | |
| 0.00459{1} | 0.01057{7} | 0.00631{4} | 0.01037{6} | 0.00495{2} | 0.00587{3} | 0.00738{5} | |||
| 0.26867{1} | 0.37392{6} | 0.29871{4} | 0.37399{7} | 0.27240{2} | 0.29187{3} | 0.36747{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.19213{1} | 0.27009{5} | 0.21942{4} | 0.27324{6} | 0.19622{2} | 0.20883{3} | 0.28640{7} | ||
| 0.13546{1} | 0.20566{7} | 0.15883{4} | 0.20367{6} | 0.14078{2} | 0.15317{3} | 0.17182{5} | |||
| 9.0{1} | 54.0{6} | 36.0{4} | 57.0{7} | 18.0{2} | 27.0{3} | 51.0{5} | |||
| 0.72747{1} | 0.97899{6} | 0.80542{4} | 1.00442{7} | 0.73222{2} | 0.79536{3} | 0.97361{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.34845{1} | 0.48718{5} | 0.38562{3} | 0.49124{6} | 0.35156{2} | 0.39104{4} | 0.50148{7} | ||
| 0.05915{1} | 0.08784{6} | 0.06773{4} | 0.09129{7} | 0.05978{2} | 0.06705{3} | 0.07480{5} | |||
| 0.52921{1} | 0.95843{6} | 0.64870{4} | 1.00887{7} | 0.53615{2} | 0.63260{3} | 0.94792{5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.12142{1} | 0.23734{5} | 0.14870{3} | 0.24131{6} | 0.12360{2} | 0.15291{4} | 0.25148{7} | |
| 0.00350{1} | 0.00772{6} | 0.00459{4} | 0.00833{7} | 0.00357{2} | 0.00450{3} | 0.00560{5} | |||
| 0.24249{1} | 0.32633{6} | 0.26847{4} | 0.33481{7} | 0.24407{2} | 0.26512{3} | 0.32454{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.17423{1} | 0.24359{5} | 0.19281{3} | 0.24562{6} | 0.17578{2} | 0.19552{4} | 0.25074{7} | ||
| 0.11830{1} | 0.17569{6} | 0.13545{4} | 0.18258{7} | 0.11957{2} | 0.13411{3} | 0.14961{5} | |||
| 9.0{1} | 51.0{5.5} | 33.0{4} | 60.0{7} | 18.0{2} | 30.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.42368{2} | 0.57365{7} | 0.44019{3} | 0.56734{6} | 0.39367{1} | 0.46296{4} | 0.55727{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.20329{2} | 0.28118{5} | 0.22107{3} | 0.28147{6} | 0.17295{1} | 0.23061{4} | 0.29062{7} | ||
| 0.03492{2} | 0.05134{6} | 0.03862{3} | 0.05141{7} | 0.03021{1} | 0.03907{4} | 0.04410{5} | |||
| 0.17950{2} | 0.32907{7} | 0.19377{3} | 0.32187{6} | 0.15497{1} | 0.21433{4} | 0.31055{5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.04133{2} | 0.07906{5} | 0.04887{3} | 0.07923{6} | 0.02991{1} | 0.05318{4} | 0.08446{7} | |
| 0.00122{2} | 0.00264{6.5} | 0.00149{3} | 0.00264{6.5} | 0.00091{1} | 0.00153{4} | 0.00195{5} | |||
| 0.14123{2} | 0.19122{7} | 0.14673{3} | 0.18911{6} | 0.13122{1} | 0.15432{4} | 0.18576{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.10164{2} | 0.14059{5} | 0.11053{3} | 0.14074{6} | 0.08648{1} | 0.11531{4} | 0.14531{7} | ||
| 0.06985{2} | 0.10268{6} | 0.07723{3} | 0.10282{7} | 0.06042{1} | 0.07814{4} | 0.08821{5} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 54.5{6} | 27.0{3} | 56.5{7} | 9.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5} | |||
| 0.31666{2} | 0.43372{5} | 0.34594{3} | 0.44379{7} | 0.05705{1} | 0.35603{4} | 0.44102{6} | |||
| BIAS | 0.15894{2} | 0.21239{5} | 0.17117{3} | 0.21484{6} | 0.11282{1} | 0.17722{4} | 0.23302{7} | ||
| 0.02612{2} | 0.03988{6} | 0.03001{3} | 0.04067{7} | 0.02268{1} | 0.03051{4} | 0.03389{5} | |||
| 0.10027{2} | 0.18811{5} | 0.11968{3} | 0.19695{7} | 0.00325{1} | 0.12676{4} | 0.19450{6} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.02526{2} | 0.04511{5} | 0.02930{3} | 0.04616{6} | 0.01273{1} | 0.03141{4} | 0.05430{7} | |
| 0.00068{2} | 0.00159{6} | 0.00090{3} | 0.00165{7} | 0.00051{1} | 0.00093{4} | 0.00115{5} | |||
| 0.10555{2} | 0.14457{5} | 0.11531{3} | 0.14793{7} | 0.01902{1} | 0.11868{4} | 0.14701{6} | |||
| MRE | 0.07947{2} | 0.10620{5} | 0.08559{3} | 0.10742{6} | 0.05641{1} | 0.08861{4} | 0.11651{7} | ||
| 0.05224{2} | 0.07975{6} | 0.06001{3} | 0.08133{7} | 0.04536{1} | 0.06101{4} | 0.06778{5} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 48.0{5} | 27.0{3} | 60.0{7} | 9.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 54.0{6} |
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.42172{1} | 0.57424{7} | 0.50458{4} | 0.57303{6} | 0.42428{2} | 0.43142{3} | 0.53491{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.74503{1} | 1.02601{6} | 0.87498{4} | 0.99396{5} | 0.76302{2} | 0.79326{3} | 1.04921{7} | ||
| 0.60323{2} | 0.83924{7} | 0.72169{4} | 0.83175{6} | 0.59830{1} | 0.61337{3} | 0.73835{5} | |||
| 0.17785{1} | 0.32975{7} | 0.25460{4} | 0.32837{6} | 0.18001{2} | 0.18612{3} | 0.28612{5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.55507{1} | 1.05270{6} | 0.76559{4} | 0.98797{5} | 0.58220{2} | 0.62926{3} | 1.10085{7} | |
| 0.36388{2} | 0.70432{7} | 0.52083{4} | 0.69182{6} | 0.35797{1} | 0.37623{3} | 0.54516{5} | |||
| 0.56230{1} | 0.76565{7} | 0.67278{4} | 0.76404{6} | 0.56571{2} | 0.57522{3} | 0.71321{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.37251{1} | 0.51301{6} | 0.43749{4} | 0.49698{5} | 0.38151{2} | 0.39663{3} | 0.52461{7} | ||
| 0.40215{2} | 0.55949{7} | 0.48112{4} | 0.55450{6} | 0.39887{1} | 0.40891{3} | 0.49223{5} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 60.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} | 15.0{2} | 27.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.24584{1} | 0.34864{6} | 0.27997{4} | 0.35745{7} | 0.24991{2} | 0.26879{3} | 0.34626{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.43540{1} | 0.63631{5} | 0.49653{3} | 0.64512{6} | 0.45069{2} | 0.49849{4} | 0.67553{7} | ||
| 0.34382{1} | 0.51140{6} | 0.40168{4} | 0.52632{7} | 0.35419{2} | 0.38432{3} | 0.47426{5} | |||
| 0.06044{1} | 0.12155{6} | 0.07838{4} | 0.12777{7} | 0.06245{2} | 0.07225{3} | 0.11989{5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.18957{1} | 0.40490{5} | 0.24654{3} | 0.41618{6} | 0.20312{2} | 0.24850{4} | 0.45634{7} | |
| 0.11821{1} | 0.26153{6} | 0.16134{4} | 0.27702{7} | 0.12545{2} | 0.14770{3} | 0.22492{5} | |||
| 0.32779{1} | 0.46486{6} | 0.37329{4} | 0.47660{7} | 0.33321{2} | 0.35839{3} | 0.46168{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.21770{1} | 0.31816{5} | 0.24827{3} | 0.32256{6} | 0.22535{2} | 0.24925{4} | 0.33777{7} | ||
| 0.22921{1} | 0.34093{6} | 0.26778{4} | 0.35088{7} | 0.23612{2} | 0.25621{3} | 0.31617{5} | |||
| 9.0{1} | 51.0{5.5} | 33.0{4} | 60.0{7} | 18.0{2} | 30.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.22403{2} | 0.31942{7} | 0.23891{3} | 0.31925{6} | 0.21762{1} | 0.24604{4} | 0.30050{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.40735{2} | 0.56195{5} | 0.43483{3} | 0.57730{6} | 0.40013{1} | 0.44494{4} | 0.58704{7} | ||
| 0.31320{2} | 0.46026{6} | 0.34414{3} | 0.46805{7} | 0.30932{1} | 0.34696{4} | 0.40286{5} | |||
| 0.05019{2} | 0.10203{7} | 0.05708{3} | 0.10192{6} | 0.04736{1} | 0.06054{4} | 0.09030{5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.16594{2} | 0.31579{5} | 0.18908{3} | 0.33327{6} | 0.16010{1} | 0.19797{4} | 0.34462{7} | |
| 0.09809{2} | 0.21184{6} | 0.11843{3} | 0.21907{7} | 0.09568{1} | 0.12038{4} | 0.16230{5} | |||
| 0.29871{2} | 0.42590{7} | 0.31854{3} | 0.42567{6} | 0.29016{1} | 0.32806{4} | 0.40067{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.20368{2} | 0.28098{5} | 0.21741{3} | 0.28865{6} | 0.20006{1} | 0.22247{4} | 0.29352{7} | ||
| 0.20880{2} | 0.30684{6} | 0.22943{3} | 0.31203{7} | 0.20621{1} | 0.23131{4} | 0.26858{5} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 54.0{6} | 27.0{3} | 57.0{7} | 9.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5} | |||
| 0.12397{1} | 0.18442{6} | 0.13681{3} | 0.19156{7} | 0.12571{2} | 0.14237{4} | 0.17920{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.22906{1} | 0.33171{5} | 0.24706{3} | 0.34894{6} | 0.23285{2} | 0.25831{4} | 0.35679{7} | ||
| 0.17568{2} | 0.26853{6} | 0.19072{3} | 0.27352{7} | 0.17123{1} | 0.20423{4} | 0.23953{5} | |||
| 0.01537{1} | 0.03401{6} | 0.01872{3} | 0.03670{7} | 0.01580{2} | 0.02027{4} | 0.03211{5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.05247{1} | 0.11003{5} | 0.06104{3} | 0.12176{6} | 0.05422{2} | 0.06672{4} | 0.12730{7} | |
| 0.03086{2} | 0.07211{6} | 0.03637{3} | 0.07481{7} | 0.02932{1} | 0.04171{4} | 0.05737{5} | |||
| 0.16529{1} | 0.24590{6} | 0.18241{3} | 0.25542{7} | 0.16761{2} | 0.18982{4} | 0.23893{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.11453{1} | 0.16585{5} | 0.12353{3} | 0.17447{6} | 0.11643{2} | 0.12916{4} | 0.17839{7} | ||
| 0.11712{2} | 0.17902{6} | 0.12715{3} | 0.18234{7} | 0.11415{1} | 0.13615{4} | 0.15968{5} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 51.0{5.5} | 27.0{3} | 60.0{7} | 15.0{2} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.09502{1} | 0.14651{6} | 0.10324{3} | 0.14789{7} | 0.09760{2} | 0.11155{4} | 0.14061{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.17342{2} | 0.25702{5} | 0.18680{3} | 0.26567{6} | 0.16564{1} | 0.20379{4} | 0.26977{7} | ||
| 0.13259{2} | 0.21317{7} | 0.14517{3} | 0.21208{6} | 0.12653{1} | 0.15936{4} | 0.18936{5} | |||
| 0.00903{1} | 0.02147{6} | 0.01066{3} | 0.02187{7} | 0.00953{2} | 0.01244{4} | 0.01977{5} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.03007{2} | 0.06606{5} | 0.03489{3} | 0.07058{6} | 0.02744{1} | 0.04153{4} | 0.07277{7} | |
| 0.01758{2} | 0.04544{7} | 0.02107{3} | 0.04498{6} | 0.01601{1} | 0.02540{4} | 0.03586{5} | |||
| 0.12670{1} | 0.19535{6} | 0.13765{3} | 0.19719{7} | 0.13014{2} | 0.14874{4} | 0.18748{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.08671{2} | 0.12851{5} | 0.09340{3} | 0.13283{6} | 0.08282{1} | 0.10190{4} | 0.13488{7} | ||
| 0.08839{2} | 0.14211{7} | 0.09678{3} | 0.14139{6} | 0.08435{1} | 0.10624{4} | 0.12624{5} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 54.0{6} | 27.0{3} | 57.0{7} | 12.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5} |
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.71191{4} | 0.78264{7} | 0.70816{3} | 0.76040{6} | 0.66802{1} | 0.67976{2} | 0.73203{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.09484{2} | 0.11084{6} | 0.10181{4} | 0.11035{5} | 0.09794{3} | 0.09481{1} | 0.11937{7} | ||
| 0.11737{2} | 0.15240{7} | 0.13500{5} | 0.15101{6} | 0.11535{1} | 0.11866{3} | 0.11902{4} | |||
| 0.50681{4} | 0.61253{7} | 0.50149{3} | 0.57822{6} | 0.44625{1} | 0.46207{2} | 0.53586{5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.00899{1.5} | 0.01229{6} | 0.01037{4} | 0.01218{5} | 0.00959{3} | 0.00899{1.5} | 0.01425{7} | |
| 0.01377{2} | 0.02323{7} | 0.01822{5} | 0.02280{6} | 0.01331{1} | 0.01408{3} | 0.01417{4} | |||
| 0.47460{4} | 0.52176{7} | 0.47211{3} | 0.50694{6} | 0.44535{1} | 0.45317{2} | 0.48802{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.18968{2} | 0.22169{6} | 0.20362{4} | 0.22071{5} | 0.19587{3} | 0.18962{1} | 0.23874{7} | ||
| 0.23473{2} | 0.30481{7} | 0.27000{5} | 0.30202{6} | 0.23071{1} | 0.23733{3} | 0.23805{4} | |||
| 23.5{3} | 60.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{6} | 15.0{1} | 18.5{2} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.42498{4} | 0.46003{6} | 0.42394{3} | 0.48181{7} | 0.40274{1} | 0.42227{2} | 0.44965{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.05453{1} | 0.06595{5} | 0.05880{4} | 0.06677{6} | 0.05682{2} | 0.05823{3} | 0.07008{7} | ||
| 0.06856{1} | 0.09180{6} | 0.07478{5} | 0.09219{7} | 0.06880{2} | 0.07182{4} | 0.07172{3} | |||
| 0.18061{4} | 0.21163{6} | 0.17973{3} | 0.23214{7} | 0.16220{1} | 0.17831{2} | 0.20218{5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.00297{1} | 0.00435{5} | 0.00346{4} | 0.00446{6} | 0.00323{2} | 0.00339{3} | 0.00491{7} | |
| 0.00470{1} | 0.00843{6} | 0.00559{5} | 0.00850{7} | 0.00473{2} | 0.00516{4} | 0.00514{3} | |||
| 0.28332{4} | 0.30669{6} | 0.28263{3} | 0.32121{7} | 0.26850{1} | 0.28151{2} | 0.29976{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.10905{1} | 0.13190{5} | 0.11760{4} | 0.13355{6} | 0.11364{2} | 0.11646{3} | 0.14015{7} | ||
| 0.13712{1} | 0.18361{6} | 0.14956{5} | 0.18437{7} | 0.13760{2} | 0.14363{4} | 0.14343{3} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 51.0{6} | 36.0{4} | 60.0{7} | 15.0{1} | 27.0{3} | 45.0{5} | |||
| 0.37645{2} | 0.41873{6} | 0.39679{4} | 0.41977{7} | 0.36523{1} | 0.37858{3} | 0.39810{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.04801{1} | 0.05964{6} | 0.05340{4} | 0.05912{5} | 0.04976{2} | 0.05189{3} | 0.06171{7} | ||
| 0.06022{1} | 0.07999{6} | 0.06842{5} | 0.08104{7} | 0.06113{2} | 0.06520{4} | 0.06451{3} | |||
| 0.14171{2} | 0.17533{6} | 0.15744{4} | 0.17621{7} | 0.13339{1} | 0.14332{3} | 0.15848{5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.00230{1} | 0.00356{6} | 0.00285{4} | 0.00350{5} | 0.00248{2} | 0.00269{3} | 0.00381{7} | |
| 0.00363{1} | 0.00640{6} | 0.00468{5} | 0.00657{7} | 0.00374{2} | 0.00425{4} | 0.00416{3} | |||
| 0.25096{2} | 0.27915{6} | 0.26453{4} | 0.27985{7} | 0.24349{1} | 0.25239{3} | 0.26540{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.09601{1} | 0.11929{6} | 0.10680{4} | 0.11825{5} | 0.09951{2} | 0.10378{3} | 0.12342{7} | ||
| 0.12044{1} | 0.15997{6} | 0.13683{5} | 0.16209{7} | 0.12226{2} | 0.13041{4} | 0.12903{3} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 54.0{6} | 39.0{4} | 57.0{7} | 15.0{2} | 30.0{3} | 45.0{5} | |||
| 0.20467{1} | 0.24398{6} | 0.22662{4} | 0.25065{7} | 0.20658{2} | 0.21942{3} | 0.22712{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.02747{1} | 0.03469{6} | 0.02947{3} | 0.03315{5} | 0.02801{2} | 0.03009{4} | 0.03626{7} | ||
| 0.03332{1} | 0.04706{6} | 0.03898{5} | 0.04820{7} | 0.03353{2} | 0.03716{4} | 0.03690{3} | |||
| 0.04189{1} | 0.05953{6} | 0.05136{4} | 0.06283{7} | 0.04268{2} | 0.04814{3} | 0.05158{5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.00075{1} | 0.00120{6} | 0.00087{3} | 0.00110{5} | 0.00078{2} | 0.00091{4} | 0.00131{7} | |
| 0.00111{1} | 0.00221{6} | 0.00152{5} | 0.00232{7} | 0.00112{2} | 0.00138{4} | 0.00136{3} | |||
| 0.13645{1} | 0.16266{6} | 0.15108{4} | 0.16710{7} | 0.13772{2} | 0.14628{3} | 0.15142{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.05495{1} | 0.06937{6} | 0.05894{3} | 0.06630{5} | 0.05602{2} | 0.06018{4} | 0.07252{7} | ||
| 0.06665{1} | 0.09412{6} | 0.07796{5} | 0.09639{7} | 0.06706{2} | 0.07433{4} | 0.07380{3} | |||
| 9.0{1} | 54.0{6} | 36.0{4} | 57.0{7} | 18.0{2} | 33.0{3} | 45.0{5} | |||
| 0.16748{2} | 0.19256{7} | 0.16870{3} | 0.19072{6} | 0.16725{1} | 0.17112{4} | 0.18424{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.02220{2} | 0.02659{5} | 0.02387{4} | 0.02674{6} | 0.02209{1} | 0.02313{3} | 0.02814{7} | ||
| 0.02676{2} | 0.03681{7} | 0.02896{4} | 0.03658{6} | 0.02653{1} | 0.02875{3} | 0.02923{5} | |||
| 0.02805{2} | 0.03708{7} | 0.02846{3} | 0.03637{6} | 0.02797{1} | 0.02928{4} | 0.03395{5} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.00049{1.5} | 0.00071{5} | 0.00057{4} | 0.00072{6} | 0.00049{1.5} | 0.00053{3} | 0.00079{7} | |
| 0.00072{2} | 0.00136{7} | 0.00084{4} | 0.00134{6} | 0.00070{1} | 0.00083{3} | 0.00085{5} | |||
| 0.11165{2} | 0.12837{7} | 0.11246{3} | 0.12715{6} | 0.11150{1} | 0.11408{4} | 0.12283{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.04439{2} | 0.05317{5} | 0.04773{4} | 0.05349{6} | 0.04417{1} | 0.04626{3} | 0.05627{7} | ||
| 0.05352{2} | 0.07363{7} | 0.05792{4} | 0.07317{6} | 0.05305{1} | 0.05750{3} | 0.05846{5} | |||
| 17.5{2} | 57.0{7} | 33.0{4} | 54.0{6} | 9.5{1} | 30.0{3} | 51.0{5} |
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.44196{2} | 1.69204{6} | 1.50686{4} | 1.74484{7} | 1.41440{1} | 1.46484{3} | 1.60815{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.09835{1} | 0.12618{5} | 0.11039{4} | 0.12722{6} | 0.10605{3} | 0.10380{2} | 0.13179{7} | ||
| 0.57603{2} | 0.73125{7} | 0.62770{5} | 0.72313{6} | 0.55467{1} | 0.58443{3} | 0.62115{4} | |||
| 2.07924{2} | 2.86300{6} | 2.27062{4} | 3.04447{7} | 2.00052{1} | 2.14575{3} | 2.58614{5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.00967{1} | 0.01592{5} | 0.01219{4} | 0.01619{6} | 0.01125{3} | 0.01077{2} | 0.01737{7} | |
| 0.33181{2} | 0.53473{7} | 0.39401{5} | 0.52292{6} | 0.30766{1} | 0.34156{3} | 0.38582{4} | |||
| 0.48065{2} | 0.56401{6} | 0.50229{4} | 0.58161{7} | 0.47147{1} | 0.48828{3} | 0.53605{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.19669{1} | 0.25236{5} | 0.22078{4} | 0.25445{6} | 0.21210{3} | 0.20759{2} | 0.26357{7} | ||
| 0.38402{2} | 0.48750{7} | 0.41847{5} | 0.48209{6} | 0.36978{1} | 0.38962{3} | 0.41410{4} | |||
| 15.0{1.5} | 54.0{6} | 39.0{4} | 57.0{7} | 15.0{1.5} | 24.0{3} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.86852{2} | 1.05648{6} | 0.92675{4} | 1.11411{7} | 0.85049{1} | 0.91682{3} | 0.97671{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.05995{1} | 0.07473{5} | 0.06625{4} | 0.07788{6} | 0.06069{2} | 0.06248{3} | 0.08012{7} | ||
| 0.34488{2} | 0.45143{6} | 0.37538{5} | 0.47545{7} | 0.33018{1} | 0.36698{3} | 0.37375{4} | |||
| 0.75432{2} | 1.11616{6} | 0.85887{4} | 1.24125{7} | 0.72333{1} | 0.84055{3} | 0.95397{5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.00359{1} | 0.00558{5} | 0.00439{4} | 0.00607{6} | 0.00368{2} | 0.00390{3} | 0.00642{7} | |
| 0.11894{2} | 0.20379{6} | 0.14091{5} | 0.22606{7} | 0.10902{1} | 0.13467{3} | 0.13969{4} | |||
| 0.28951{2} | 0.35216{6} | 0.30892{4} | 0.37137{7} | 0.28350{1} | 0.30561{3} | 0.32557{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.11990{1} | 0.14945{5} | 0.13251{4} | 0.15576{6} | 0.12138{2} | 0.12496{3} | 0.16024{7} | ||
| 0.22992{2} | 0.30096{6} | 0.25025{5} | 0.31697{7} | 0.22012{1} | 0.24465{3} | 0.24917{4} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 51.0{6} | 39.0{4} | 60.0{7} | 12.0{1} | 27.0{3} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.75610{1} | 0.96527{7} | 0.82996{4} | 0.96330{6} | 0.78031{2} | 0.80111{3} | 0.86594{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.05237{1} | 0.06765{6} | 0.05654{4} | 0.06640{5} | 0.05369{2} | 0.05541{3} | 0.06972{7} | ||
| 0.29658{1} | 0.40519{7} | 0.34089{4} | 0.40424{6} | 0.30493{2} | 0.32993{3} | 0.34092{5} | |||
| 0.57168{1} | 0.93174{7} | 0.68883{4} | 0.92794{6} | 0.60888{2} | 0.64178{3} | 0.74985{5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.00274{1} | 0.00458{6} | 0.00320{4} | 0.00441{5} | 0.00288{2} | 0.00307{3} | 0.00486{7} | |
| 0.08796{1} | 0.16418{7} | 0.11621{4} | 0.16341{6} | 0.09298{2} | 0.10886{3} | 0.11623{5} | |||
| 0.25203{1} | 0.32176{7} | 0.27665{4} | 0.32110{6} | 0.26010{2} | 0.26704{3} | 0.28865{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.10474{1} | 0.13530{6} | 0.11307{4} | 0.13280{5} | 0.10737{2} | 0.11083{3} | 0.13945{7} | ||
| 0.19772{1} | 0.27013{7} | 0.22726{4} | 0.26950{6} | 0.20329{2} | 0.21996{3} | 0.22728{5} | |||
| 9.0{1} | 60.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} | 18.0{2} | 27.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.44661{2} | 0.57449{7} | 0.45941{3} | 0.55834{6} | 0.40301{1} | 0.48267{4} | 0.51675{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.03041{1} | 0.03986{6} | 0.03241{3} | 0.03737{5} | 0.03042{2} | 0.03329{4} | 0.04069{7} | ||
| 0.17477{2} | 0.24359{7} | 0.18902{3} | 0.24097{6} | 0.13908{1} | 0.19177{4} | 0.20436{5} | |||
| 0.19946{2} | 0.33004{7} | 0.21106{3} | 0.31175{6} | 0.16242{1} | 0.23297{4} | 0.26703{5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.00092{1} | 0.00159{6} | 0.00105{3} | 0.00140{5} | 0.00093{2} | 0.00111{4} | 0.00166{7} | |
| 0.03055{2} | 0.05933{7} | 0.03573{3} | 0.05806{6} | 0.01934{1} | 0.03677{4} | 0.04176{5} | |||
| 0.14887{2} | 0.19150{7} | 0.15314{3} | 0.18611{6} | 0.13434{1} | 0.16089{4} | 0.17225{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.06082{1} | 0.07972{6} | 0.06482{3} | 0.07473{5} | 0.06084{2} | 0.06658{4} | 0.08137{7} | ||
| 0.11651{2} | 0.16239{7} | 0.12602{3} | 0.16064{6} | 0.09272{1} | 0.12784{4} | 0.13624{5} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 60.0{7} | 27.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | 12.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.34256{2} | 0.44063{7} | 0.34721{3} | 0.43195{6} | 0.02944{1} | 0.37626{4} | 0.39231{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.02400{2} | 0.03049{6} | 0.02499{3} | 0.02981{5} | 0.02191{1} | 0.02528{4} | 0.03148{7} | ||
| 0.13510{2} | 0.18960{7} | 0.14366{3} | 0.18545{6} | 0.07460{1} | 0.15145{4} | 0.15185{5} | |||
| 0.11735{2} | 0.19416{7} | 0.12056{3} | 0.18658{6} | 0.00087{1} | 0.14157{4} | 0.15390{5} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.00058{2} | 0.00093{6} | 0.00062{3} | 0.00089{5} | 0.00048{1} | 0.00064{4} | 0.00099{7} | |
| 0.01825{2} | 0.03595{7} | 0.02064{3} | 0.03439{6} | 0.00556{1} | 0.02294{4} | 0.02306{5} | |||
| 0.11419{2} | 0.14688{7} | 0.11574{3} | 0.14398{6} | 0.00981{1} | 0.12542{4} | 0.13077{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.04801{2} | 0.06099{6} | 0.04997{3} | 0.05963{5} | 0.04382{1} | 0.05055{4} | 0.06296{7} | ||
| 0.09007{2} | 0.12640{7} | 0.09577{3} | 0.12364{6} | 0.04973{1} | 0.10097{4} | 0.10123{5} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 60.0{7} | 27.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | 9.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} |
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.35033{1} | 0.45753{6} | 0.54028{7} | 0.35423{2} | 0.43731{4.5} | 0.36102{3} | 0.43731{4.5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.65498{2} | 0.84455{5} | 0.37021{1} | 0.66749{3} | 0.88746{6.5} | 0.69873{4} | 0.88746{6.5} | ||
| 0.12022{1} | 0.17120{6} | 0.28452{7} | 0.12145{2} | 0.14491{4.5} | 0.12795{3} | 0.14491{4.5} | |||
| 0.12273{1} | 0.20933{7} | 0.16419{4} | 0.12548{2} | 0.19124{5.5} | 0.13033{3} | 0.19124{5.5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.42900{1} | 0.71326{5} | 0.54822{4} | 0.44554{2} | 0.78759{6.5} | 0.48822{3} | 0.78759{6.5} | |
| 0.01445{1} | 0.02931{7} | 0.02024{4} | 0.01475{2} | 0.02100{5.5} | 0.01637{3} | 0.02100{5.5} | |||
| 0.46710{2} | 0.61003{7} | 0.40521{1} | 0.47231{3} | 0.58308{5.5} | 0.48136{4} | 0.58308{5.5} | |||
| MRE | 0.32749{1} | 0.42227{4} | 0.74042{7} | 0.33374{2} | 0.44373{5.5} | 0.34936{3} | 0.44373{5.5} | ||
| 0.24044{2} | 0.34241{7} | 0.14226{1} | 0.24289{3} | 0.28981{5.5} | 0.25591{4} | 0.28981{5.5} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 54.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 21.0{2} | 49.5{5.5} | 30.0{3} | 49.5{5.5} | |||
| 0.20179{2} | 0.27857{6} | 0.30512{7} | 0.20107{1} | 0.26896{4.5} | 0.21287{3} | 0.26896{4.5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.38707{2} | 0.53325{5} | 0.22052{1} | 0.39326{3} | 0.56475{6.5} | 0.41982{4} | 0.56475{6.5} | ||
| 0.06616{1} | 0.10016{6} | 0.15995{7} | 0.06842{2} | 0.08461{4.5} | 0.07368{3} | 0.08461{4.5} | |||
| 0.04072{2} | 0.07760{7} | 0.05237{4} | 0.04043{1} | 0.07234{5.5} | 0.04531{3} | 0.07234{5.5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.14983{1} | 0.28436{5} | 0.19451{4} | 0.15465{2} | 0.31894{6.5} | 0.17625{3} | 0.31894{6.5} | |
| 0.00438{1} | 0.01003{7} | 0.00640{4} | 0.00468{2} | 0.00716{5.5} | 0.00543{3} | 0.00716{5.5} | |||
| 0.26905{3} | 0.37142{7} | 0.22884{1} | 0.26810{2} | 0.35861{5.5} | 0.28383{4} | 0.35861{5.5} | |||
| MRE | 0.19354{1} | 0.26663{4} | 0.44103{7} | 0.19663{2} | 0.28237{5.5} | 0.20991{3} | 0.28237{5.5} | ||
| 0.13232{2} | 0.20032{7} | 0.07997{1} | 0.13684{3} | 0.16922{5.5} | 0.14736{4} | 0.16922{5.5} | |||
| 15.0{1} | 54.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 18.0{2} | 49.5{5.5} | 30.0{3} | 49.5{5.5} | |||
| 0.18500{2} | 0.25608{6} | 0.27807{7} | 0.17408{1} | 0.24411{4.5} | 0.20231{3} | 0.24411{4.5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.35037{3} | 0.49218{5} | 0.20165{1} | 0.34995{2} | 0.51120{6.5} | 0.39421{4} | 0.51120{6.5} | ||
| 0.05903{1} | 0.09138{6} | 0.14213{7} | 0.06020{2} | 0.07569{4.5} | 0.06835{3} | 0.07569{4.5} | |||
| 0.03422{2} | 0.06558{7} | 0.04350{4} | 0.03030{1} | 0.05959{5.5} | 0.04093{3} | 0.05959{5.5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.12276{2} | 0.24224{5} | 0.16265{4} | 0.12247{1} | 0.26133{6.5} | 0.15540{3} | 0.26133{6.5} | |
| 0.00349{1} | 0.00835{7} | 0.00505{4} | 0.00362{2} | 0.00573{5.5} | 0.00467{3} | 0.00573{5.5} | |||
| 0.24666{3} | 0.34144{7} | 0.20855{1} | 0.23210{2} | 0.32548{5.5} | 0.26975{4} | 0.32548{5.5} | |||
| MRE | 0.17518{2} | 0.24609{4} | 0.40330{7} | 0.17498{1} | 0.25560{5.5} | 0.19710{3} | 0.25560{5.5} | ||
| 0.11807{2} | 0.18275{7} | 0.07107{1} | 0.12040{3} | 0.15139{5.5} | 0.13671{4} | 0.15139{5.5} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 54.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 15.0{1} | 49.5{5.5} | 30.0{3} | 49.5{5.5} | |||
| 0.09983{1} | 0.14352{6} | 0.15355{7} | 0.10039{2} | 0.13550{4.5} | 0.11555{3} | 0.13550{4.5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.19849{2} | 0.28408{5} | 0.11199{1} | 0.20130{3} | 0.29346{6.5} | 0.22521{4} | 0.29346{6.5} | ||
| 0.03315{1} | 0.05220{6} | 0.07953{7} | 0.03462{2} | 0.04282{4.5} | 0.03962{3} | 0.04282{4.5} | |||
| 0.00997{1} | 0.02060{7} | 0.01326{3} | 0.01008{2} | 0.01836{5.5} | 0.01335{4} | 0.01836{5.5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.03940{1} | 0.08070{5} | 0.05017{3} | 0.04052{2} | 0.08612{6.5} | 0.05072{4} | 0.08612{6.5} | |
| 0.00110{1} | 0.00272{7} | 0.00158{4} | 0.00120{2} | 0.00183{5.5} | 0.00157{3} | 0.00183{5.5} | |||
| 0.13311{2} | 0.19137{7} | 0.11516{1} | 0.13386{3} | 0.18067{5.5} | 0.15406{4} | 0.18067{5.5} | |||
| MRE | 0.09924{1} | 0.14204{4} | 0.22398{7} | 0.10065{2} | 0.14673{5.5} | 0.11261{3} | 0.14673{5.5} | ||
| 0.06630{2} | 0.10439{7} | 0.03977{1} | 0.06923{3} | 0.08564{5.5} | 0.07923{4} | 0.08564{5.5} | |||
| 12.0{1} | 54.0{7} | 34.0{4} | 21.0{2} | 49.5{5.5} | 32.0{3} | 49.5{5.5} | |||
| 0.07766{2} | 0.11386{6} | 0.11696{7} | 0.07683{1} | 0.10434{4.5} | 0.08623{3} | 0.10434{4.5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.15565{2} | 0.21937{5} | 0.08564{1} | 0.15772{3} | 0.22284{6.5} | 0.17202{4} | 0.22284{6.5} | ||
| 0.02562{2} | 0.04004{6} | 0.06012{7} | 0.02550{1} | 0.03365{4.5} | 0.02965{3} | 0.03365{4.5} | |||
| 0.00603{2} | 0.01296{7} | 0.00769{4} | 0.00590{1} | 0.01089{5.5} | 0.00744{3} | 0.01089{5.5} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.02423{1} | 0.04813{5} | 0.02933{3} | 0.02488{2} | 0.04966{6.5} | 0.02959{4} | 0.04966{6.5} | |
| 0.00066{2} | 0.00160{7} | 0.00090{4} | 0.00065{1} | 0.00113{5.5} | 0.00088{3} | 0.00113{5.5} | |||
| 0.10355{3} | 0.15181{7} | 0.08772{1} | 0.10244{2} | 0.13911{5.5} | 0.11497{4} | 0.13911{5.5} | |||
| MRE | 0.07783{1} | 0.10969{4} | 0.17127{7} | 0.07886{2} | 0.11142{5.5} | 0.08601{3} | 0.11142{5.5} | ||
| 0.05125{3} | 0.08008{7} | 0.03006{1} | 0.05100{2} | 0.06730{5.5} | 0.05931{4} | 0.06730{5.5} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 54.0{7} | 35.0{4} | 15.0{1} | 49.5{5.5} | 31.0{3} | 49.5{5.5} |
| Est. | Est. Par. | MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.82272{1} | 1.17051{7} | 1.00884{4} | 1.13921{6} | 0.86375{3} | 0.85938{2} | 1.0715{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.72236{1} | 1.02020{5} | 0.89204{4} | 1.02715{6} | 0.76335{2} | 0.78657{3} | 1.06928{7} | ||
| 0.58169{1} | 0.83673{7} | 0.71925{4} | 0.82518{6} | 0.59881{2} | 0.62772{3} | 0.73020{5} | |||
| 0.67686{1} | 1.37008{7} | 1.01775{4} | 1.29780{6} | 0.74606{3} | 0.73853{2} | 1.14810{5} | |||
| 30 | MSE | 0.52180{1} | 1.04080{5} | 0.79573{4} | 1.05503{6} | 0.58270{2} | 0.61869{3} | 1.14335{7} | |
| 0.33836{1} | 0.70012{7} | 0.51732{4} | 0.68092{6} | 0.35857{2} | 0.39403{3} | 0.53320{5} | |||
| 0.54848{1} | 0.78034{7} | 0.67256{4} | 0.75947{6} | 0.57583{3} | 0.57292{2} | 0.71433{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.36118{1} | 0.51010{5} | 0.44602{4} | 0.51357{6} | 0.38167{2} | 0.39328{3} | 0.53464{7} | ||
| 0.38779{1} | 0.55782{7} | 0.47950{4} | 0.55012{6} | 0.39921{2} | 0.41848{3} | 0.48680{5} | |||
| 9.0{1} | 57.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 54.0{6} | 21.0{2} | 24.0{3} | 51.0{5} | |||
| 0.49804{2} | 0.72479{7} | 0.58439{4} | 0.72298{6} | 0.48981{1} | 0.55086{3} | 0.67489{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.45446{2} | 0.64825{7} | 0.52473{4} | 0.63570{5} | 0.44444{1} | 0.48552{3} | 0.64301{6} | ||
| 0.34350{1} | 0.52277{7} | 0.41424{4} | 0.51841{6} | 0.34928{2} | 0.39698{3} | 0.45441{5} | |||
| 0.24804{2} | 0.52532{7} | 0.34151{4} | 0.52269{6} | 0.23991{1} | 0.30344{3} | 0.45547{5} | |||
| 80 | MSE | 0.20653{2} | 0.42023{7} | 0.27534{4} | 0.40412{5} | 0.19753{1} | 0.23573{3} | 0.41347{6} | |
| 0.11799{1} | 0.27328{7} | 0.17159{4} | 0.26875{6} | 0.12200{2} | 0.15759{3} | 0.20649{5} | |||
| 0.33202{2} | 0.48319{7} | 0.38959{4} | 0.48198{6} | 0.32654{1} | 0.36724{3} | 0.44992{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.22723{2} | 0.32413{7} | 0.26236{4} | 0.31785{5} | 0.22222{1} | 0.24276{3} | 0.32151{6} | ||
| 0.22900{1} | 0.34851{7} | 0.27616{4} | 0.34561{6} | 0.23285{2} | 0.26465{3} | 0.30294{5} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 63.0{7} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{6} | 12.0{1} | 27.0{3} | 48.0{5} | |||
| 0.42927{1} | 0.65573{7} | 0.49781{4} | 0.63655{6} | 0.44759{2} | 0.48927{3} | 0.63378{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.38669{1} | 0.59203{6} | 0.44666{3} | 0.57252{5} | 0.41076{2} | 0.44670{4} | 0.61439{7} | ||
| 0.30647{1} | 0.47299{7} | 0.35886{4} | 0.46302{6} | 0.31459{2} | 0.34601{3} | 0.41967{5} | |||
| 0.18427{1} | 0.42998{7} | 0.24781{4} | 0.40520{6} | 0.20034{2} | 0.23939{3} | 0.40168{5} | |||
| 100 | MSE | 0.14953{1} | 0.35050{6} | 0.19950{3} | 0.32778{5} | 0.16872{2} | 0.19954{4} | 0.37747{7} | |
| 0.09392{1} | 0.22372{7} | 0.12878{4} | 0.21439{6} | 0.09896{2} | 0.11972{3} | 0.17612{5} | |||
| 0.28618{1} | 0.43715{7} | 0.33187{4} | 0.42437{6} | 0.29840{2} | 0.32618{3} | 0.42252{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.19335{1} | 0.29602{6} | 0.22333{3} | 0.28626{5} | 0.20538{2} | 0.22335{4} | 0.30719{7} | ||
| 0.20431{1} | 0.31532{7} | 0.23924{4} | 0.30868{6} | 0.20972{2} | 0.23067{3} | 0.27978{5} | |||
| 9.0{1} | 60.0{7} | 33.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} | 18.0{2} | 30.0{3} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.24936{1} | 0.36485{6} | 0.28494{3} | 0.38158{7} | 0.25562{2} | 0.28529{4} | 0.36160{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.22467{2} | 0.32956{5} | 0.24855{3} | 0.34611{6} | 0.22002{1} | 0.26118{4} | 0.34790{7} | ||
| 0.17451{2} | 0.26813{6} | 0.20160{3} | 0.27122{7} | 0.17133{1} | 0.20287{4} | 0.23938{5} | |||
| 0.06218{1} | 0.13312{6} | 0.08119{3} | 0.14560{7} | 0.06534{2} | 0.08139{4} | 0.13075{5} | |||
| 300 | MSE | 0.05048{2} | 0.10861{5} | 0.06178{3} | 0.11979{6} | 0.04841{1} | 0.06822{4} | 0.12103{7} | |
| 0.03045{2} | 0.07189{6} | 0.04064{3} | 0.07356{7} | 0.02935{1} | 0.04116{4} | 0.05730{5} | |||
| 0.16624{1} | 0.24323{6} | 0.18996{3} | 0.25438{7} | 0.17041{2} | 0.19019{4} | 0.24106{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.11233{2} | 0.16478{5} | 0.12428{3} | 0.17306{6} | 0.11001{1} | 0.13059{4} | 0.17395{7} | ||
| 0.11634{2} | 0.17875{6} | 0.13440{3} | 0.18081{7} | 0.11422{1} | 0.13525{4} | 0.15959{5} | |||
| 15.0{2} | 51.0{5.5} | 27.0{3} | 60.0{7} | 12.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5.5} | |||
| 0.19292{2} | 0.29228{6} | 0.21255{3} | 0.29493{7} | 0.16821{1} | 0.22580{4} | 0.28260{5} | |||
| BIAS | 0.17568{2} | 0.26739{6} | 0.19333{3} | 0.26126{5} | 0.13532{1} | 0.20934{4} | 0.27913{7} | ||
| 0.13619{2} | 0.21229{6} | 0.15372{3} | 0.21392{7} | 0.10918{1} | 0.15987{4} | 0.18837{5} | |||
| 0.03722{2} | 0.08543{6} | 0.04518{3} | 0.08698{7} | 0.02829{1} | 0.05098{4} | 0.07986{5} | |||
| 500 | MSE | 0.03086{2} | 0.07149{6} | 0.03738{3} | 0.06826{5} | 0.01831{1} | 0.04382{4} | 0.07792{7} | |
| 0.01855{2} | 0.04507{6} | 0.02363{3} | 0.04576{7} | 0.01192{1} | 0.02556{4} | 0.03548{5} | |||
| 0.12861{2} | 0.19485{6} | 0.14170{3} | 0.19662{7} | 0.11214{1} | 0.15053{4} | 0.18840{5} | |||
| MRE | 0.08784{2} | 0.13369{6} | 0.09667{3} | 0.13063{5} | 0.06766{1} | 0.10467{4} | 0.13957{7} | ||
| 0.09079{2} | 0.14153{6} | 0.10248{3} | 0.14261{7} | 0.07279{1} | 0.10658{4} | 0.12558{5} | |||
| 18.0{2} | 54.0{6} | 27.0{3} | 57.0{7} | 9.0{1} | 36.0{4} | 51.0{5} |
| MLEs | LSEs | WLSEs | CRVMEs | MPSEs | ADEs | RADEs | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 | 3 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 1 | 5 | |
| 80 | 2 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 100 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 300 | 1 | 5.5 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 500 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 30 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 2 | 3 | 5 | |
| 80 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 100 | 2 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 300 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 2 | 3 | 5 | |
| 500 | 1 | 5.5 | 3 | 7 | 2 | 4 | 5.5 | |
| 30 | 3 | 5.5 | 4 | 7 | 1 | 2 | 5.5 | |
| 80 | 1 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 3 | 5 | |
| 100 | 1 | 5.5 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 300 | 2 | 6 | 3 | 7 | 1 | 4 | 5 | |
| 500 | 2 | 5 | 3 | 7 | 1 | 4 | 6 | |
| 30 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 5.5 | 2 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 80 | 1 | 5.5 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 100 | 2 | 6 | 3 | 7 | 1 | 4 | 5 | |
| 300 | 1 | 5.5 | 3 | 7 | 2 | 4 | 5.5 | |
| 500 | 1 | 5.5 | 3 | 7 | 2 | 4 | 5.5 | |
| 30 | 3 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 1 | 2 | 5 | |
| 80 | 2 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 100 | 1 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 3 | 5 | |
| 300 | 1 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 3 | 5 | |
| 500 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 30 | 1.5 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 1.5 | 3 | 5 | |
| 80 | 2 | 6 | 4 | 7 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 100 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 5.5 | 2 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 300 | 2 | 7 | 3 | 5.5 | 1 | 4 | 5.5 | |
| 500 | 2 | 7 | 3 | 5.5 | 1 | 4 | 5.5 | |
| 30 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 2 | 5.5 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 80 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 2 | 5.5 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 100 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 1 | 5.5 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 300 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 2 | 5.5 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 500 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 1 | 5.5 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 30 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 2 | 3 | 5 | |
| 80 | 2 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| 100 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 5.5 | 2 | 3 | 5.5 | |
| 300 | 2 | 5.5 | 3 | 7 | 1 | 4 | 5.5 | |
| 500 | 2 | 6 | 3 | 7 | 1 | 4 | 5 | |
| 64.5 | 254 | 150 | 236.5 | 79 | 129 | 210 | ||
| Overall Rank | 1 | 7 | 4 | 6 | 2 | 3 | 5 |
7. Real-Life Data Analysis
In this section, the FExILL distribution is applied to three real-world data sets. The first set, sourced from Hinkley (1977), comprises thirty consecutive measurements of March precipitation (in inches) recorded in Minneapolis/St. Paul. The observed data values are: 0.81, 1.74, 0.77, 1.20, 1.20, 1.95, 0.47, 3.37, 1.43, 2.20, 3.09, 3.00, 1.51, 0.52, 2.10, 1.62, 0.32, 1.31, 0.59, 2.81, 0.81, 1.87, 1.35, 1.18, 4.75, 0.96, 2.48, 1.89, 2.05, 0.90.
The second real-world data set consists of service time measurements (in hours) for 63 aircraft windshields, as reported by Murthy et al. (2004). The recorded values begin with: 2.065, 0.046, 1.492, 2.592, 2.600, 0.140, 0.150, 2.670, 1.580, 0.248, 2.717, 1.7190, 0.2800, 2.819, 1.794, 0.3130, 2.820, 1.915, 0.389, 2.878, 1.920, 0.487, 2.950, 1.9630, 0.622, 3.0030, 1.978, 0.900, 3.1020, 2.053, 0.952, 0.9960, 3.3040, 2.117, 1.0030, 3.483, 2.137, 1.0100, 3.500, 2.141, 1.085, 3.6220, 2.163, 1.092, 3.6650, 2.183, 1.1520, 3.695, 2.240, 1.183, 4.015, 2.341, 1.244, 4.628, 2.435, 1.249, 4.806, 2.464, 1.436, 4.881, 1.262, 5.140, 2.5430.
The third data set contains the original time-to-failure records for 40 turbocharger units, as documented by Xu et al. (2003). The data values begin with: 2.0, 1.6, 8.5, 6.1, 3.0, 7.3, 2.6, 7.7, 3.5, 8.0, 4.5, 3.9, 4.6, 5.0, 4.8, 5.1, 8.8, 5.4, 5.3, 5.6, 6.0, 5.8, 6.0, 8.4, 6.7, 6.5, 7.0, 6.5, 7.1, 7.3, 6.3, 7.3, 7.8, 7.7, 7.9, 8.1, 8.4, 8.3, 8.7, 9.0.
The FExILL model is compared with other some competitive models called, the Fréchet Topp-Leone Lomax (FTLL) (Reyad et al., 2021), McDonal-Lomax (MCL), Kumaraswamy–Lomax (KwL) (Lemonte and Cordeiro, 2013), Burr-X Lomax (BXL) (Yousof et al., 2017), the odd Lomax log-logistic (OLLL) (Cordeiro et al., 2019), exponentiated Lomax (EL) (Abdul-Moniem, 2012), Topp-Leone inverse Lomax (TLIL) (Hassan and Ismail, 2021), alpha power Lomax (APL) (Bulut et al., 2021), half-logistic Lomax (HLL) (Anwar and Zahoor, 2018), Lomax-logarithmic (LL) (Al-Zahrani and Sagor, 2015), IL, and L distributions.
Fig. 6 displays the total time on test (TTT) plots for the three data sets, all of which suggest an increasing HRF. Fig. 7 illustrates the HRF curves of the FExILL distribution, derived from parameter estimates based on each data set. These curves align with the TTT plots, reinforcing the suitability of the FExILL model for modeling the given data. The ML estimates of the parameters for competing models, along with their standard errors (SEs), have been summarized in Tables 11-13 for the respective data sets. Tables 14-16 present various goodness-of-fit statistics, which indicate that the FExILL distribution outperforms other generalized LL extensions. Additionally, Figs. 8-10 offer visual comparisons through the PDF, CDF, SF, and probability-probability (PP) plots for the FExILL model across the three data sets.

- The TTT plots for March precipitation (left panel), aircraft Windshield (middle panel), and failure data (right panel) datasets.

- The HRF plots for March precipitation (left panel), aircraft windshield (middle panel), and failure data (right panel) datasets.
| Distribution | Estimates | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FExILL | 0.7115 | 3.7391 | 0.98840 | ||
| (0.6932) | (2.9820) | (0.5338) | |||
| McL | 0.2057 | 2126.4913 | 3.6745 | 4189.6837 | 0.7739 |
| (1.2955) | (699.0721) | (3.3386) | (2511.2968) | (0.7779) | |
| FTLL | 0.2629 | 300.5891 | 1.8769 | 539.4416 | 211.6519 |
| (0.0390) | (733.5824) | (3.7565) | (1.6050) | (1.1310) | |
| KwL | 20384.1998 | 19606.5576 | 3.2733 | 1.1630 | |
| (17579.6230) | (416.3407) | (1.5226) | (1.3339) | ||
| OLxLL | 100.5575 | 0.0134 | 252.7611 | 1.8215 | |
| (492.8470) | (0.0176) | (597.2891) | (0.2445) | ||
| BXL | 0.4360 | 0.3465 | 1.7601 | ||
| (0.2566) | (0.5791) | (1.4309) | |||
| EL | 3.4611 | 111771.4000 | 95773.0800 | ||
| (1.4596) | (31650.9339) | (203.8890) | |||
| TLIL | 23.4040 | 0.4911 | 0.6124 | ||
| (158.9021) | (1.0350) | (3.3012) | |||
| APL | 345.7780 | 14.6080 | 9.3450 | ||
| (1034.7376) | (39.9857) | (29.8543) | |||
| LL | 99.6899 | 0.0186 | 157.2634 | ||
| (179.3670) | (0.0349) | (388.7139) | |||
| HLL | 50.0190 | 0.0177 | |||
| (59.7709) | (0.0215) | ||||
| IL | 99.9383 | 0.0115 | |||
| 127.9619 | 0.0147 |
| Distribution | Estimates | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FExILL | 7.2308 | 0.9230 | 4.3278 | ||
| (4.8337) | (0.2774) | (2.6869) | |||
| McL | 60.7028 | 2124.7607 | 1.1949 | 4190.0342 | 3.6917 |
| 98.3339 | 1261.8036 | 0.1986 | 14196.1415 | 1.7280 | |
| FTLL | 0.1730 | 680.5261 | 2.1775 | 540.4306 | 211.2330 |
| (0.0166) | (546.2034) | (0.5490) | (0.3889) | (0.4654) | |
| KwL | 22.6234 | 14237.6126 | 1.6302 | 9369.8568 | |
| (27.3999) | (315.4126) | (0.1696) | (16250.0355) | ||
| OLxLL | 100.5463 | 0.0463 | 252.7687 | 1.6350 | |
| (258.9727) | (0.1371) | (626.7750) | (0.1700) | ||
| BXL | 4.1821 | 17.0536 | 0.5524 | ||
| (8.9978) | (41.1722) | (0.1142) | |||
| EL | 1.8799 | 80355.8600 | 117294.1000 | ||
| (0.3282) | (10398.6948) | (301.4956) | |||
| TLIL | 2.1170 | 1.7020 | 1.0760 | ||
| (2.6872) | (0.9751) | (1.2497) | |||
| APL | 28.6909 | 73464.2579 | 83713.5546 | ||
| (24.0481) | (9567.6909) | (360.7489) | |||
| LL | 118.8279 | 0.0165 | 1407.2760 | ||
| (152.2697) | (0.0225) | (4847.9887) | |||
| HLL | 50.0227 | 0.0140 | |||
| (36.8370) | (0.0104) | ||||
| IL | 2.5508 | 0.5561 | |||
| (0.8685) | (0.2449) |
| Distribution | Estimates | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FExILL | 1847.4002 | 0.6941 | 1004.8514 | ||
| (1830.0906) | (0.1425) | (1031.0275) | |||
| McL | 0.9662 | 0.0381 | 306.9175 | 1861.4810 | 1499.2050 |
| (0.2329) | (0.0218) | (270.3906) | (2100.9540) | (1876.3835) | |
| FTLL | 0.5603 | 8118.0001 | 0.0095 | 20030.0000 | 47910.0000 |
| (0.0646) | (12470.4000) | (0.0144) | (466.1780) | (571.2512) | |
| KwL | 17.8118 | 3724.7000 | 3.9112 | 661740.0000 | |
| (8.5202) | (70.4684) | (0.5459) | (16997.1148) | ||
| OLxLL | 46.0418 | 0.0134 | 55.6426 | 3.8993 | |
| (83.0662) | (0.0144) | (34.6146) | (0.5228) | ||
| BXL | 1629.2851 | 14474.7365 | 1.5509 | ||
| (118.6123) | (680.9998) | (0.3105) | |||
| EL | 9.5150 | 63830.5500 | 141890.2000 | ||
| (3.0448) | (8768.9267) | (457.2670) | |||
| TLIL | 143.6227 | 0.8259 | 0.5594 | ||
| (1055.5074) | (1.7767) | (3.1302) | |||
| APL | 209519.5300 | 34656.4600 | 72362.8100 | ||
| (16782.2372) | (2249.7287) | (410.4981) | |||
| LL | 88.1158 | 0.0068 | 180.8977 | ||
| (106.1205) | (0.0083) | (137.7786) | |||
| HLL | 52.0862 | 0.0047 | |||
| 20.8767 | 0.0018 | ||||
| IL | 99.9046 | 0.0533 | |||
| (180.7576) | (0.0970) |
| Distribution | AIC | CAIC | BIC | HQIC | P-value | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FExILL | 82.1121 | 83.0352 | 86.3157 | 83.4570 | 0.0143 | 0.1038 | 38.0561 | 0.0625 | 0.999802 |
| McL | 86.1305 | 88.6305 | 93.1365 | 88.3718 | 0.0144 | 0.1042 | 38.0653 | 0.0630 | 0.999769 |
| FTLL | 86.6644 | 89.1644 | 93.6704 | 88.9057 | 0.0149 | 0.1149 | 38.3322 | 0.0700 | 0.998534 |
| KwL | 84.1872 | 85.7872 | 89.7920 | 85.9802 | 0.0146 | 0.1053 | 38.0936 | 0.0626 | 0.999796 |
| OLxLL | 85.2365 | 86.8365 | 90.8413 | 87.0295 | 0.0214 | 0.1655 | 38.6182 | 0.0676 | 0.999162 |
| BXL | 82.1436 | 83.0667 | 86.3472 | 83.4884 | 0.0144 | 0.1044 | 38.0718 | 0.0630 | 0.999770 |
| EL | 82.1885 | 83.1116 | 86.3921 | 83.5333 | 0.0152 | 0.1083 | 38.0943 | 0.0655 | 0.999514 |
| TLIL | 86.9053 | 87.8284 | 91.1089 | 88.2501 | 0.0760 | 0.4709 | 40.4526 | 0.1155 | 0.818597 |
| APL | 82.9157 | 83.8388 | 87.1193 | 84.2605 | 0.0161 | 0.1195 | 38.4578 | 0.0647 | 0.999620 |
| LL | 88.2237 | 89.1467 | 92.4272 | 89.5684 | 0.0479 | 0.3299 | 41.1118 | 0.1424 | 0.576697 |
| HLL | 89.4877 | 89.9322 | 92.2901 | 90.3842 | 0.0151 | 0.1177 | 42.7439 | 0.1923 | 0.217236 |
| IL | 96.6912 | 97.1357 | 99.4936 | 97.5877 | 0.0830 | 0.5140 | 46.3456 | 0.2548 | 0.040664 |
| Distribution | AIC | CAIC | BIC | HQIC | P-value | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FExILL | 202.2569 | 202.6637 | 208.6863 | 204.7856 | 0.0363 | 0.2452 | 98.1284 | 0.0668 | 0.923824 |
| McL | 206.6628 | 207.7154 | 217.3785 | 210.8773 | 0.0491 | 0.3139 | 98.3314 | 0.0772 | 0.819058 |
| FTLL | 209.1741 | 210.2267 | 219.8897 | 213.3886 | 0.0851 | 0.5047 | 99.5870 | 0.1072 | 0.433855 |
| KwL | 208.6722 | 209.3618 | 217.2447 | 212.0438 | 0.1048 | 0.6353 | 100.3361 | 0.1090 | 0.412801 |
| OLxLL | 208.7831 | 209.4727 | 217.3556 | 212.1547 | 0.1061 | 0.6433 | 100.3915 | 0.1092 | 0.410991 |
| BXL | 202.4959 | 202.9027 | 208.9253 | 205.0246 | 0.0459 | 0.2988 | 98.2480 | 0.0721 | 0.874986 |
| EL | 213.0992 | 213.5060 | 219.5286 | 215.6279 | 0.2032 | 1.2300 | 103.5496 | 0.1417 | 0.144358 |
| TLIL | 231.7116 | 232.1183 | 238.1410 | 234.2403 | 0.4372 | 2.5912 | 112.8558 | 0.1431 | 0.137078 |
| APL | 206.7111 | 207.1179 | 213.1406 | 209.2399 | 0.0975 | 0.5930 | 100.3556 | 0.1056 | 0.452207 |
| LL | 204.0118 | 204.4186 | 210.4412 | 206.5405 | 0.0484 | 0.3169 | 99.0059 | 0.0980 | 0.547289 |
| HLL | 212.6155 | 212.8155 | 216.9018 | 214.3013 | 0.1270 | 0.7726 | 104.3077 | 0.1653 | 0.056617 |
| IL | 248.8840 | 249.0840 | 253.1703 | 250.5698 | 0.6180 | 3.5629 | 122.4420 | 0.2305 | 0.001996 |
| Distribution | AIC | CAIC | BIC | HQIC | P-value | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FExILL | 166.2765 | 166.9432 | 171.3431 | 168.1084 | 0.0330 | 0.2435 | 80.1383 | 0.0909 | 0.895863 |
| McL | 177.2589 | 179.0236 | 185.7033 | 180.3121 | 0.1135 | 0.8176 | 83.6294 | 0.1344 | 0.465702 |
| FTLL | 188.5174 | 190.2821 | 196.9618 | 191.5706 | 0.2439 | 1.5821 | 89.2587 | 0.1552 | 0.290415 |
| KwL | 173.1086 | 174.2515 | 179.8642 | 175.5512 | 0.0790 | 0.5866 | 82.5543 | 0.1083 | 0.736169 |
| OLxLL | 173.2599 | 174.4027 | 180.0154 | 175.7025 | 0.0799 | 0.5924 | 82.6299 | 0.1076 | 0.743881 |
| BXL | 170.9086 | 171.5753 | 175.9753 | 172.7405 | 0.0797 | 0.5908 | 82.4543 | 0.1111 | 0.706889 |
| EL | 186.2860 | 186.9526 | 191.3526 | 188.1179 | 0.2758 | 1.7601 | 90.1430 | 0.1542 | 0.297515 |
| TLIL | 206.8750 | 207.5417 | 211.9416 | 208.7069 | 0.5100 | 2.9947 | 100.4375 | 0.2813 | 0.003569 |
| APL | 183.9854 | 184.6521 | 189.0520 | 185.8173 | 0.2340 | 1.5269 | 88.9927 | 0.1518 | 0.315644 |
| LL | 204.2716 | 204.9383 | 209.3383 | 206.1036 | 0.0990 | 0.7181 | 99.1358 | 0.3473 | 0.000129 |
| HLL | 218.6917 | 219.0160 | 222.0695 | 219.9130 | 0.1785 | 1.2049 | 107.3459 | 0.3438 | 0.000156 |
| IL | 233.4837 | 233.8080 | 236.8614 | 234.7049 | 0.4394 | 2.6333 | 114.7418 | 0.4454 | 0.000000 |

- The fitted PDF, CDF, SF, and PP plots of the FEXILL distribution for March precipitation data in Minneapolis.

- The fitted PDF, CDF, SF, and PP plots of the FEXILL distribution for service times of aircraft windshield data.

- The fitted PDF, CDF, SF, and PP plots of the FEXILL distribution for turbochargers failure data.
In addition, Figs. 11-13 provide histogram-based visual comparisons between the FExILL distribution and several well-established lifetime models. For each dataset, the histogram is overlaid with the fitted density curves of all competing distributions. These visualizations offer an intuitive and direct assessment of the relative goodness-of-fit, thereby complementing the numerical results.

- Histograms of March precipitation in Minneapolis with the fitted densities of the FEXILL distribution and competing models.

- Histograms of service times of aircraft windshield data with the fitted densities of the FEXILL distribution and competing models.

- Histograms of turbochargers failure data with the fitted densities of the FEXILL distribution and competing models.
8. Conclusions
This study introduced the FEx-G family, a broad class of probability distributions that generalizes several well-known models while retaining attractive statistical properties. Key theoretical results, including quantile function, moments, skewness, kurtosis, and characterizations via the HR function, were established to highlight its versatility. A notable submodel, the FEx inverse Lomax-Lomax (FExILL) distribution, was investigated in greater detail. Various estimation techniques were applied and evaluated through simulation studies under different parameter settings and sample sizes, showing consistent and reliable performance. Applications to multiple real data sets further confirmed that the FExILL distribution provides a superior fit over competing exponential-type models, underscoring its practical value for statisticians and applied researchers.
In addition to the above findings, this study opens several avenues for future research. First, the proposed FEx-G family and its special case (FExILL distribution) can be further extended to regression frameworks and survival analysis models, allowing the inclusion of covariates in practical settings. Second, Bayesian estimation approaches may be explored to complement the classical methods considered here, particularly for small sample scenarios or censored data. Third, further applications in fields such as reliability engineering, biomedical survival data, and financial risk modeling would provide deeper insights into the flexibility and practical relevance of the model. Finally, new subfamilies of the FEx-G distribution could be derived to handle more complex data structures, such as heavy-tailed or skewed data, which would significantly broaden its applicability.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Jamal N. Al Abbasi: Writingoriginal draft, conceptualization, methodology, Writing, review & editing; Ibrahim Elbatal: Methodology, writingoriginal draft, data interpretation, Writing, review & editing; Ahmed Z. Afify: Writingoriginal draft, software, data interpretation, project administration, Writing, review & editing; Hisham A. Mahran: Writingoriginal draft, software, data interpretation, Writing, review & editing. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have influenced the work presented in this paper.
Data availability
The datasets are mentioned in the paper.
Declaration of Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process
The authors confirm that there was no use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)-Assisted Technology for assisting in the writing or editing of the manuscript and no images were manipulated using AI.
Funding
This work was supported and funded by the Deanship of Scientific Research at Imam Mohammad Ibn Saud Islamic University (IMSIU)(grant number IMSIU-DDRSP2502).
References
- Recurrence relations for moments of lower generalized order statistics from exponentiated Lomax distribution and its characterization. J. Math. Comput. Sci.. 2012;2:999-1011. https://scik.org/index.php/jmcs/article/view/236.
- [Google Scholar]
- The Marshall–Olkin–Weibull-H family: Estimation, simulations, and applications to COVID-19 data. J King Saud Univ Sci. 2022;34:102115. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jksus.2022.102115
- [Google Scholar]
- Generalized beta-generated distributions. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis. 2012;56:1880-1897. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.csda.2011.11.015
- [Google Scholar]
- The weighted Lindley-G family of probabilistic models: Properties, inference, and applications to real-life data. IFS. 2023;44:8071-8089. https://doi.org/10.3233/jifs-222758
- [Google Scholar]
- Statistical analysis of the Lomax logarithmic distribution. J Stat Computation Simulation. 2015;85:1883-1901. https://doi.org/10.1080/00949655.2014.907800
- [Google Scholar]
- Exponentiated T-X family of distributions with some applications. Int J Statist Probab. 2013;2:31-49. https://doi.org/10.5539/ijsp.v2n3p31
- [Google Scholar]
- The half-logistic lomax distribution for lifetime modeling. J Probability Statistics. 2018;2018:1-12. https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/3152807
- [Google Scholar]
- A new shifted Lomax-X family of distributions: properties and applications to actuarial and financial data. Computational J Math Stat Sci. 2025;4:41-71. https://doi.org/10.21608/cjmss.2024.307114.1066
- [Google Scholar]
- A class of distributions which includes the normal ones. Scand. J Statist. 1985;12:171-178. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4615982
- [Google Scholar]
- A new power Topp–Leone generated family of distributions with applications. Entropy. 2019;21:1177. https://doi.org/10.3390/e21121177
- [Google Scholar]
- A flexible Weibull extension. Reliab Eng Syst Saf. 2007;92:719-726. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ress.2006.03.004
- [Google Scholar]
- Alpha power Lomax distribution: Properties and application. JRSS. 2021 https://doi.org/10.13052/jrss0974-8024.1412
- [Google Scholar]
- Maximum product of spacings estimation with application to the lognormal distribution. Math Rep, University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology, Cardiff 1979:79-81.
- [Google Scholar]
- Estimating parameters in continuous univariate distributions with a shifted origin. J R Stat Soc Ser B Stat Methodol. 1983;45:394-403. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2517-6161.1983.tb01268.x
- [Google Scholar]
- A new family of generalized distributions. J Stat Computation Simulation. 2011;81:883-898. https://doi.org/10.1080/00949650903530745
- [Google Scholar]
- The exponentiated generalized class of distributions. J Data Sci. 2013;11:1-27. https://doi.org/10.6339/JDS.2013.11(1).1086
- [Google Scholar]
- The odd Lomax generator of distributions: Properties, estimation and applications. J Comput Appl Math. 2019;347:222-237. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cam.2018.08.008
- [Google Scholar]
- On the composition of elementary errors. Scand Actuar J. 1928;1928:13-74. https://doi.org/10.1080/03461238.1928.10416862
- [Google Scholar]
- Beta-normal distribution and its applications. Commun. Stat Theory Methods. 2002;31:497-512. http://dx.doi.org/10.1081/STA-120003130
- [Google Scholar]
- The modified Kies flexible generalized family: Properties, simulations, and applications. AJS. 2024;53:25-42. https://doi.org/10.17713/ajs.v53i4.1789
- [Google Scholar]
- Modeling failure time data by Lehmann alternatives. Commun Stat Theory Methods. 1998;27:887-904. https://doi.org/10.1080/03610929808832134
- [Google Scholar]
- The modified Kies-Kavya-Manoharan family: Properties, inference, and applications. ADAS. 2025;92:861-887. https://doi.org/10.17654/0972361725036
- [Google Scholar]
- Estimation of parameters of Topp–Leone inverse Lomax distribution in presence of right censored samples. Gazi Univ J Sci. 2021;34:1193-1208. https://doi.org/10.35378/gujs.773645
- [Google Scholar]
- On quick choice of power transformation. Appl Stat. 1977;26:67. https://doi.org/10.2307/2346869
- [Google Scholar]
- Measuring skewness: We do not assume much. Scientia Iranica. 2021;28:3525-3537. https://doi.org/10.24200/SCI.2020.52306.2649
- [Google Scholar]
- The strength of glass performance. Naval Research Lab Report No. 5093. 1958. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40300-013-0018-8
- An extended Lomax distribution. Statistics. 2013;47:800-816. https://doi.org/10.1080/02331888.2011.568119
- [Google Scholar]
- A New flexible bathtub‐shaped modification of the Weibull model: properties and applications. Math Probl Eng. 2020;2020:3206257. https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/3206257
- [Google Scholar]
- A new method for generating distributions with an application to exponential distribution. Communications in Statistics - Theory and Methods. 2017;46:6543-6557. https://doi.org/10.1080/03610926.2015.1130839
- [Google Scholar]
- A new one-parameter flexible family with variable failure rate shapes: Properties, inference, and real-life applications. AIMS Math. 2024;9:11910-11940. https://doi.org/10.3934/math.2024582
- [Google Scholar]
- A new method for adding a parameter to a family of distributions with application to the exponential and Weibull families. Biometrika. 1997;84:641-652. https://doi.org/10.1093/biomet/84.3.641
- [Google Scholar]
- Sine modified-Kies generalized family of distributions: properties and applications. Physica Scripta. 2025;100:085009. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1402-4896/adeed7/meta
- [Google Scholar]
- Weibull Models. Wiley; 2004.
- A new flexible generalized family for generating continuous models. Scientific African. 2025;28:e02723. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sciaf.2025.e02723
- [Google Scholar]
- Sine generalized family of distributions: Properties, estimation, simulations and applications. Alexandria Eng J. 2024;109:532-552. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aej.2024.09.001
- [Google Scholar]
- The Fréchet Topp Leone-G family of distributions: properties, characterizations and applications. Ann Data Sci. 2021;8:345-366. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40745-019-00212-9
- [Google Scholar]
- New logistic family of distributions: Applications to reliability engineering. Axioms. 2025;14:643. https://doi.org/10.3390/axioms14080643
- [Google Scholar]
- Least squares estimation of distribution function in Johnsons translation system. J Stat Comput Simul. 1988;29:271-297. https://doi.org/10.1080/00949658808811068
- [Google Scholar]
- The logistic-X family of distributions and its applications. Communications in Statistics - Theory and Methods. 2016;45:7326-7349. https://doi.org/10.1080/03610926.2014.980516
- [Google Scholar]
- Wahrscheinlichkeit Statistik und Wahrheit. Basel: Springer; 1928.
- Application of neural networks in forecasting engine systems reliability. Applied Soft Computing. 2003;2:255-268. https://doi.org/10.1016/s1568-4946(02)00059-5
- [Google Scholar]
- The Burr X generator of distributions for lifetime data. JSTA. 2017;16:288. https://doi.org/10.2991/jsta.2017.16.3.2
- [Google Scholar]
